If the case had ended there, it would have simply been a shocking tragedy. Fred Duncan Jr. would still be the prime culprit, but the situation wouldn't exactly be soul-crushing.
But after Jie Jie and Hanna issued an alert for Todd Carter and Vicky Brokaw's vehicle via the Pennsylvania State Police system, they quickly received a response.
In a small town called Bryn Mawr, a family had just been slaughtered. An elderly couple in their sixties had been killed. Neighbors heard gunshots and called 911. When the police arrived, they found an older Infiniti sedan in the driveway.
The vehicle matched the one Todd Carter and Vicky Brokaw were driving.
The task force arrived soon after—only to discover the corpses of Todd and Vicky in the trunk of the car.
The case suddenly grew far more complex. Jubal speculated that Fred Jr. had them killed to cover his tracks, but that didn't explain the brutal condition of the elderly couple inside the home.
The victims were Dan and Sally Wiggins. Dan had been shot in the head with what forensics later confirmed was the same 9mm handgun Todd Carter used at the amusement center.
Sally had been savagely beaten to death with a fireplace poker—found right by her mutilated body. The crime scene was horrific.
It was clearly a crime of rage, a personal vendetta.
Alice dug into Sally Wiggins' past, specifically her financials. When she looked into a pre-marriage bank account, she uncovered a series of unusual deposits totaling over $250,000—spread out over a year, more than 30 years ago.
In the early 1990s, that kind of money was staggering.
The source of those deposits was quickly traced to a company called FD Entertainment—owned by none other than Fred Duncan Sr., Fred Jr.'s father.
Fred Sr. died in 2010. Fred Jr. inherited his estate and the family's network of amusement parks, bowling alleys, and entertainment centers—but his poor management had driven them into the red, leading to the desperate insurance scam to pay off his son William's gambling debt.
That financial link proved crucial. The team refocused on Sally Wiggins and uncovered that she had been the only witness in a 35-year-old rape and murder case.
Back then, a girl named Jessica Brooke had died in the Duncan family's old estate. She was the daughter of their gardener. The convicted killer? A young man named Angelo Carpenter.
At the time, Angelo had been working as a tutor for Fred Jr. The night Jessica died, only three people were in the house: Angelo Carpenter, Fred Jr., and the housekeeper—Sally Wiggins.
The prosecution's entire case had hinged on Sally's testimony. She claimed she saw Angelo assault Jessica and then push her down the stairs, killing her.
But for 35 years, Angelo had maintained his innocence. He insisted that Fred Sr. had bribed Sally to lie under oath to protect his son, Fred Jr., the real killer.
Angelo had appealed for decades, to no avail. From a naive young man, he grew old in prison—released just three weeks ago after completing his sentence.
His revenge began immediately.
First, he went looking for Fred Jr.'s son William, but he arrived at the amusement center too late—by then, the place was already engulfed in flames.
He saw William lying in a pool of blood and assumed he was dead. In a symbolic gesture, Angelo left the word Sicarius—Latin for "assassin"—on an old 1980s arcade machine, then tailed the two arsonists.
He murdered Todd and Vicky, and from them obtained a burner phone number belonging to Fred Jr. But rather than going after him immediately, he drove—with their bodies still in the trunk—to Sally Wiggins' home and killed her and her husband.
Meanwhile, the task force uncovered another key witness from that 35-year-old case: Fred Jr.'s daughter, Rachel Duncan—now known as Rachel Dunn.
Rachel had discovered her father's dark secret as a teenager and told her mother—only to be shocked when her mother ignored it, and her grandfather covered it up and scapegoated Angelo. Furious, she left the family and changed her surname.
She never contacted any of the Duncans again.
Once everything came to light, the task force concluded that Angelo's true targets weren't just Fred Jr.—but the entire Duncan bloodline, Rachel included.
Unfortunately, they realized this too late.
Rachel's underage daughter, Ellie, had already been abducted by Angelo. Soon after, he also captured Fred Jr.
Then came the sickening climax of Angelo's revenge—something so deranged it left even the task force shaken.
He brought both Fred Jr. and Ellie to the old Duncan estate—the scene of the crime 35 years ago.
Crucially, since Rachel had cut ties with the family, Fred Jr. didn't even know he had a granddaughter.
Inside the very bedroom where he had once attacked Jessica Brooke, Angelo laid everything bare to the two strangers—grandfather and granddaughter.
Then he turned his gun on Fred Jr. and ordered him to reenact the crime he had committed all those years ago.
And in a moment that made the whole team's stomachs churn, the now-graying Fred Jr.—under threat of death—complied.
Thankfully, the task force had tracked Angelo's route via road surveillance and guessed his destination in time.
Hanna kicked in the bedroom door just as the horror was about to unfold, possibly saving Ellie from witnessing the unthinkable.
What followed offered no catharsis. No redemption. Only bitter aftermath.
Angelo fled but was soon cornered by agents Clay and Aubrey. Unwilling to return to prison, he raised his gun—and was shot dead on the spot.
And Fred Duncan Jr., the true villain of this entire tragedy, survived—only mildly injured after Hanna delivered a justified and brutal kick between the legs.
Ellie, fortunately, was unharmed physically—but according to Jie Jie's assessment, she would need a long time in therapy to process what she'd endured.
After hearing the entire case, even Jack found himself at a loss. He didn't know how to console the team's collectively shattered psyche.
One thing was clear: this time, a good meal wouldn't fix anything.
______
(≧◡≦) ♡ Support me and read 20 chapters ahead – patreon.com/Mutter
Every 100 Power Stones = 1 extra chapter on Saturday.
Every 5 reviews = 1 extra chapter on Saturday.