After a few more moments, Andrew removed his tongue from Eva's pussy and positioned himself at her entrance. He could feel her wetness enveloping the tip of his cock as he looked at her spread out before him, ready, willing, and waiting.
At that moment, Katrina also got up from Eva's face and came over to Andrew's side. She took hold of his cock and guided it to Eva's entrance.
"Be gentle with her, Andrew. It's her first time," Katrina whispered in his ear before adding with a mischievous grin, "but not too gentle. She needs to feel what a real man can do."
"I will, I promise," Andrew replied, before looking at Eva, who stared back with nervous and excited eyes.
He leaned down and gave her a soft kiss on the lips and said, "Just relax, okay? It might hurt a little at first, but I promise it'll get better."
Eva bit her lip and nodded her head, her hands reaching up to grip his shoulders.
"Come on, Andrew. I trust you. Take me. Make me a woman."
And with that, Andrew pushed forward, sinking his cock into her tight folds inch by inch. Eva winced as she felt him stretching her for the first time, her fingernails digging into his back. But she didn't tell him to stop. She just breathed through the discomfort, trusting his words that it would get better.
And Andrew didn't rush. He took his time, letting Eva's pussy get used to his size before pushing further.
Soon, he could feel her barrier of innocence and knew this was the final moment.
"I'm going to push through now, Eva. This might hurt a bit."
"Just do it, Andrew! I want it all inside of me now!"
Without saying any more words, in a single, firm thrust, Andrew broke through her hymen, sinking completely inside her until his cock was buried deep into her womb.
"Ahhh! Nghhhh!" Eva cried out from the sudden pain that shot through her body, her eyes watering as she held onto Andrew like her life depended on it.
Andrew also groaned from the tightness of her pussy, the way her walls seemed to suck him into her. It was a feeling beyond words, and he fought the urge to start pounding her right then and there. It took all his self-control, but he held back.
Instead, he lowered his head to her lips and started kissing her in a tender and passionate way, distracting her from the pain while his hand found her breast and pulled it out of her bra.
He squeezed and teased her nipple until he could feel her body starting to relax underneath him and the pain starting to recede.
"Ahh... mhmm..." Eva whimpered against his lips, starting to feel waves of pleasure mixing with the lingering pain.
When Andrew felt she was ready, he moved out slowly till his tip almost left her, then in a smooth motion, pushed back inside. And he repeated the process again and again with a moderate pace.
"Ahhh... Andrew... It's so good... mhmm... I didn't think... it would feel like this..." Eva moaned as her hips started to move in rhythm with his thrusts, meeting him halfway.
While they were locked in their passionate dance, Katrina sat on the side playing with herself, watching the whole scene unfold with a flushed expression. She reached down between her legs, feeling her swollen nub, and began to pleasure herself in circles, her eyes focused on where their bodies joined together.
"Hmmm... Tell me, Eva... How do you feel having his thick cock in your tight pussy? Does it feel better than my tongue or finger?" Katrina teased.
Eva turned her head to look at her best friend, with tears of pleasure running down the sides of her face, and gave her a big smile before replying. "Mhmm... it's amazing, Katie... I feel like... my insides are being filled to the brim... I... ngh! I don't know how to describe it..."
Then, as Andrew started to increase the speed and strength of his thrusts, Eva lost the ability to speak, and instead her moans took over to express her rising pleasure.
Andrew noticed that Eva was enjoying herself, and he couldn't stop smiling as he drove himself into her tight pussy again and again.
The sight of her beautiful face contorted with pleasure and the fact that he was her first was a huge turn-on for him. This, combined with her incredibly tight pussy, was overwhelming in the best possible way.
With each push of his hips, her breasts bounced within her bra while her legs unconsciously wrapped around his waist, trying to pull him even deeper into herself.
The pleasure she felt sent her closer and closer to climax. This made her feel desperate for the mind-blowing release that was building up inside her.
"Andrew... I... I think... I'm close... I'm going to cum soon..." Eva cried out between her ragged breaths. "Please... don't stop... ngh!"
After hearing her plea, Andrew decided to push her over the edge. He leaned down and captured one of her erect nipples in his mouth while his other hand reached under her to grab her full ass cheek.
With a firm grip on her butt, he lifted her hips off the bed for a better angle, and in return, his thrusts became deeper, hitting spots inside her that she never knew existed.
"Ah! Ah! Ah! Nghh!" Every single thrust made Eva scream out loud while her insides felt like they were on fire. "Don't stop... please! Just like that... ahhn! I... I'm cummming!!!"
With a final, loud cry of pleasure, Eva's whole body trembled uncontrollably, and she felt a powerful orgasm wash over her.
And Andrew was not far behind. Feeling her tight pussy walls squeezing his cock like a milking machine, it was hard for him to hold his own orgasm back.
"Ungh… I'm going to cum too, Eva! I'm going to cum inside your tight pussy!" Andrew announced before burying his cock deep inside her one last time.
With a loud groan, ropes of hot cum shot out from his cock, flooding Eva's insides with his seed, painting her walls with his white, thick fluid until it started to leak out of her quivering hole.
After giving her everything he had, Andrew collapsed on top of Eva, both of them panting heavily while trying to catch their breaths.
The intensity of the experience left them exhausted but also satisfied beyond belief.