Chapter 11: The Brooklyn's Finest
The werewolf fight club beneath Kowalski's Auto Shop reeks of motor oil, spilled blood, and testosterone-fueled aggression. Fluorescent lights flicker overhead, casting everything in sickly yellow that makes shadows dance like living things. Dexter shouldn't be here—his vampire scent makes every wolf in the underground space growl with territorial unease—but Luke Garroway's invitation came with the weight of someone who understands that warriors sometimes need to witness strength to remember their own purpose.
Three hours since Dot died in flames I couldn't prevent. Three hours of carrying failure like a stone in my chest, watching smoke rise from her shop while firefighters battled supernatural accelerants. Luke heard about the attack, knew I was there, knew I tried. His text was simple: "Come watch something honest for once."
[SPECIES ENERGY: VITALITY 70/100, LUNAR ESSENCE 100/100]
[SPECIES CONFLICT: 35% (MANAGEABLE BUT TAXING)]
[WARNING: VAMPIRE-WEREWOLF PROXIMITY CAUSING PHYSIOLOGICAL STRESS]
The system interface tracks his deteriorating condition while fifty werewolves circle a makeshift fighting ring. Pack members in human form but carrying lupine grace, all muscle and barely contained violence, watching their alpha face a challenge that could reshape their entire social structure.
Luke Garroway stands in the ring's center, forty-something but still carrying the disciplined strength of his Shadowhunter training. Scars map his exposed torso—evidence of battles fought in two worlds, wounds that healed human and werewolf both. Across from him, Alaric Rodriguez circles with predatory patience, twenty years younger and carrying the kind of hunger that comes from waiting too long for power.
I know how this ends. Watched it play out in another world where Luke's victory came at great personal cost, where pack politics nearly destroyed everything Clary cared about. But that was television drama. This is real flesh and blood and the kind of violence that leaves permanent marks.
"You're not pack," Alaric calls out, voice carrying easily over the crowd's low murmur. "Ex-Shadowhunter, ex-Circle, ex-everything. What gives you the right to lead wolves when you've spent decades serving angels?"
Luke's response is quietly devastating. "I earned the right by bleeding for it. By choosing loyalty over easy answers. By proving that strength isn't about who you used to serve, but who you protect now."
Politics wrapped in personal challenge. Alaric isn't just questioning Luke's leadership—he's questioning whether reformed Circle members deserve redemption, whether people can truly change their fundamental nature.
The fight begins with explosive violence. Alaric moves with pure werewolf aggression, all claws and snapping teeth, while Luke responds with tactical precision learned through decades of supernatural warfare. But age shows in subtle ways—slower reflexes, deeper exhaustion, the accumulation of old injuries that never quite healed properly.
This is where it goes wrong in canon. Alaric cheats, uses silver-laced weapons to gain advantage, nearly kills Luke before pack law exposes the deception. But I'm here now, with vampire senses that can track details human eyes miss.
Alaric's brass knuckles catch the light for a split second as he adjusts his grip, and Dexter's enhanced vision sees what others miss—silver threading through the metal, illegal weapons that would burn werewolf flesh like acid.
"The moon is made of silver bullets and broken promises—WATCH THE BRASS!"
The words explode from Dexter's throat, mangled by his curse into apparent nonsense. But Luke's ears catch something beneath the scrambled warning, tactical instincts responding to urgency even when logic can't parse meaning.
He sidesteps Alaric's next punch, grabbing the younger wolf's wrist and twisting until the illegal weapons clatter to the concrete floor. Silver-laced brass knuckles, clearly visible under fluorescent light, evidence of cheating that turns pack sentiment instantly against the challenger.
Pack law is absolute about fair combat. Silver weapons in a dominance fight are grounds for permanent exile, possibly death. Alaric just destroyed any claim to leadership by proving he can't win through strength alone.
"Cheater," someone spits from the crowd. "Coward."
"No honor," another voice adds. "No right to lead."
Luke doesn't press his advantage through violence. Instead, he steps back, letting pack judgment fall on Alaric naturally. The younger wolf's supporters melt away like smoke, leaving him isolated in the center of hostile territory.
"Pack law," Luke says simply. "Fair combat or exile. Your choice."
Alaric chooses exile, disappearing into Brooklyn's maze of alleys and shadows while the pack turns its attention to more important matters—celebrating their alpha's victory and the wisdom that prevented unnecessary bloodshed.
POV: Luke Garroway
The pack run begins at midnight, thirty werewolves moving through Brooklyn's industrial wasteland with supernatural grace. Luke leads from the front, setting pace that pushes everyone's limits while maintaining formation discipline learned through decades of leading soldiers into impossible battles.
The photographer keeps up. Impossible for a mundane, even one with vampire contracts. He moves with borrowed speed but human determination, proving himself worthy of pack attention through effort rather than natural ability.
They stop at the Gowanus Canal, where toxic water reflects city lights like fallen stars. Pack members shift to human form, breathing hard from exertion but energized by the freedom that comes from running under open sky.
"You saved my leadership tonight," Luke says to Dexter, who's collapsed against a shipping container while his body processes conflicting species energies. "That warning about silver—how did you see what others missed?"
"Enhanced perception comes with the vampire contract," Dexter manages between gasping breaths. "Downside is everything gives me headaches now."
Truth wrapped in understatement. The photographer carries himself like someone in constant pain, fighting battles on multiple fronts simultaneously. Vampire and mundane, knowledge and ignorance, power and helplessness.
"Why did you warn me?" Luke continues, genuinely curious. "You could have let Alaric cheat, watched pack law sort itself out naturally. Some might say that would serve your vampire allies better."
"Because," Dexter replies, struggling to his feet with obvious effort, "leadership through cheating isn't leadership at all. It's just another form of bullying."
Moral clarity despite supernatural corruption. The kind of principle that Luke recognizes from his own journey away from Circle extremism toward something resembling wisdom.
Luke makes his decision. "I want to offer you pack membership. Not just alliance—full inclusion. But it requires clan contract, binding you to our collective rather than just individual relationships."
"Vampire and werewolf contracts," Maia Roberts observes from nearby, her voice carrying the wariness of someone who's survived too many impossible situations. "That's going to hurt."
"Everything worthwhile hurts," Dexter replies, and Luke hears decades of accumulated pain in those simple words.
The ritual begins under the full moon's silver light, pack members forming protective circle while Luke prepares the binding ceremony. Ancient words in languages that predate human civilization, blood mixed with lupine power, the kind of magic that changes people in fundamental ways.
Luke cuts his palm with ceremonial silver—the only time werewolves willingly embrace their weakness—and extends his hand to Dexter.
"Pack is family," Luke intones, voice carrying the authority of someone who's earned respect through sacrifice. "Pack is loyalty. Pack protects pack, always."
"Pack protects pack," Dexter repeats, taking Luke's bloodied hand in his own. "Always."
POV: Dexter Hale
Power floods through him like liquid fire, wild and primal and utterly different from vampire coldness. Werewolf abilities pour into his system—enhanced senses that make the world explode with new information, pack bonds that connect him to thirty other minds simultaneously, lunar energy that pulses with moon phase rhythms.
Too much. Way too much sensory input combined with existing vampire contracts. My body is trying to process ice and fire simultaneously, predator instincts that contradict each other, power sources that were never meant to coexist.
The pain hits like electric current running through every nerve ending. Vampire cold meets werewolf heat in his bloodstream, creating reactions that make him scream and convulse while pack members hold him down to prevent injury.
"Ice water," someone shouts—Maia's voice, cutting through agony with practical urgency. "Shock his system before the rejection kills him."
They drag him to the canal's edge, plunging him into water that's probably toxic but definitely freezing. The cold shocks his overloaded nervous system into temporary stability, giving vampire and werewolf energies time to find balance instead of war.
[SECOND MAJOR CONTRACT ESTABLISHED: LUKE'S PACK - CLAN LEVEL]
[WEREWOLF BOND LEVEL: 1→3 (ACCELERATED DUE TO ALPHA APPROVAL)]
[ABILITIES UNLOCKED: ENHANCED SENSES (UPGRADED), PACK TELEPATHY (1-MILE RANGE)]
[WEREWOLF AFFINITY: 25→45 (NEUTRAL-FRIENDLY)]
[NEW RESOURCE: LUNAR ESSENCE 100/100]
[WARNING: SPECIES CONFLICT INCREASED TO 40%]
[CONSTANT ENERGY DRAIN: 5 POINTS PER HOUR FROM BOTH POOLS]
When he surfaces from the canal, coughing up water that tastes like industrial runoff, thirty werewolves study him with expressions ranging from curiosity to concern. His enhanced senses now carry lupine elements—scent tracking that reveals emotional states, pack telepathy that makes him aware of every wolf within a mile radius, connection to lunar cycles that will influence his abilities for the rest of his supernatural existence.
I can feel them all. Every pack member's emotional state, their locations scattered across Brooklyn, their collective strength flowing through bonds I never asked for but desperately needed. It's intimate and overwhelming and completely addictive.
"How do you feel?" Luke asks, offering a hand to help him out of the water.
"Like my body is being pulled in two directions by forces that want to kill each other," Dexter admits, accepting the assistance with gratitude. "But also stronger. More connected."
"Species conflict is manageable with proper meditation," Maia adds, studying him with the analytical eye of someone who's survived her own supernatural transformations. "Just don't push both contracts simultaneously unless you want to die screaming."
Noted. Though given the number of impossible situations I keep finding myself in, simultaneous contract usage might not be optional.
The pack disperses as dawn approaches, wolves melting back into human disguises before returning to mundane responsibilities. Luke lingers, clearly wanting to discuss terms and expectations for their new relationship, but exhaustion weighs on Dexter like physical pressure.
Constant energy drain from species conflict. Five points per hour from both vampire and werewolf pools, meaning I'll need to manage resources more carefully than ever. Power always comes with prices.
"Training tomorrow," Luke says finally. "You need to learn pack dynamics, understand how telepathy works, practice managing dual contracts without dying. Can you handle that?"
"Do I have a choice?"
"There's always a choice. That's what makes pack membership meaningful."
Choice. Right. Except my choices have been narrowing with each supernatural contract, each step deeper into politics I barely understand, each failure to save people I care about.
His phone buzzes with messages as he walks back toward his studio. Raphael: "I heard you took a dog contract. Brave or suicidal?" Before he can formulate a response that won't trigger vampire-werewolf political complications, Aria calls in obvious panic.
"Simon's at the Institute and something's wrong with Clary," she says without preamble. "Magnus says it's about the Cup and they need everyone now."
The memory restoration. Magnus is finally unlocking what Valentine stole from Clary's mind, revealing the Mortal Cup's location after days of careful preparation. But the timeline is still accelerated, events compressed by my interference into patterns I don't fully understand.
"I'm on my way," Dexter promises, though his body aches from species conflict and his energy pools are already draining toward dangerous levels.
+1 CHAPTER AFTER EVERY 3 REVIEWS
MORE POWER STONES == MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron . PS (One patreon member can make this or any of my fanfic update weekly since some will stop after hiting 20 to 25 chapters.)
Love [ Shadowhunters: A Contract with the Night ]? Unlock More Chapters and Support the Story!
Dive deeper into the world of [ Shadowhunters: A Contract with the Night ] with exclusive access to 24+ chapters on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!