Chapter 11: Helena Bertinelli's Shadow
Ben wasn't looking for her—not consciously—but his feet carried him to the coffee shop on Fifth Street where he remembered Oliver and Helena's first meeting from the show, and there she was. Helena Bertinelli sat alone at a corner table, attacking the newspaper's crossword puzzle with angry pen strokes that suggested the words had personally offended her.
Something about her radiated controlled violence. Not the chaotic threat of street criminals or the professional menace of Oliver's vigilante work, but something more personal. More intimate. Like watching a predator that had learned to wear human skin but hadn't quite mastered the performance.
Ben's Prescience stayed silent—no blue afterimages, no warnings of immediate danger. She wasn't threatening him, just existing in a state of barely contained fury that made the air around her table feel charged with potential energy.
"Excuse me," Ben said, approaching with his coffee. "Is this seat taken?"
Helena looked up, and Ben felt the full weight of her attention like standing in the path of a searchlight. Dark eyes that had seen too much, a face that might have been beautiful if it wasn't carved from marble and bitter experience.
"It is now," she said, gesturing to the chair across from her.
Ben sat, noting how she positioned herself to watch both the entrance and the rear exit, how her purse sat within easy reach of her right hand, how she held the pen like someone who'd learned that any object could become a weapon given sufficient motivation.
"Impressive vocabulary," he observed, glancing at the crossword. She'd filled in answers that would have stumped most college graduates. "Fourteen across—'Byzantine political maneuvering.' You went with 'machinations.'"
"Most people would have said 'scheming.'"
"Most people haven't read Machiavelli in the original Italian."
Her eyebrows rose slightly. "And you have?"
"I read a lot. Helps with insomnia."
Helena set down her pen and studied him with uncomfortable intensity. "You don't look like the type who quotes Renaissance political theorists."
"What type do I look like?"
"Someone who throws punches for a living."
Perceptive.
"I teach self-defense. Close enough."
"Self-defense implies helping people protect themselves. You move like someone who's done more than just teach blocking techniques."
The observation was uncomfortably accurate. Ben sipped his coffee, buying time to construct a response that wouldn't reveal too much while acknowledging her insight.
"Sometimes teaching protection requires understanding violence."
"Understanding it, or having lived through it?"
The question hit like a physical blow. Ben found himself staring into eyes that had seen the aftermath of real violence, that recognized the particular weight that came with surviving trauma that changed your fundamental understanding of how fragile safety really was.
"Both," he said quietly.
Something in Helena's expression shifted—not softening, exactly, but acknowledging a shared membership in a club nobody wanted to join.
"What happened?" she asked.
"She's testing me. Looking for the kind of pain that creates people like her. I can't tell her about the transmigration, but I can share the grief that came with it. The children I couldn't save. The weight of failure that followed me from one life into this one."
"Building collapse," Ben said, surprised by how easily the words came. "Earthquake damage, old construction, corners cut on safety inspections. I was inside when it came down."
"Were you alone?"
"No." The memory of those children—not from this life but somehow more real than anything in this coffee shop—rose unbidden. "There were kids. A day care center on the second floor. I tried to get them out."
"Tried?"
Ben's hands tightened around his coffee cup. "I got some of them to the exit. But the ceiling gave way before I could reach the others. They..." He stopped, the fabricated details blurring with genuine grief. "They didn't make it."
Helena leaned back in her chair, studying him with new attention. "How long ago?"
"Feels like yesterday. Feels like forever."
"The guilt doesn't go away," she said finally. "People tell you it will, that time heals everything, that it wasn't your fault. They're lying."
"Speaking from experience?"
"My mother." Helena's voice carried the kind of careful control that suggested words chosen specifically to avoid breaking. "Car accident when I was sixteen. Drunk driver ran a red light, hit her coming home from my school concert. I was supposed to ride with her, but I stayed behind to talk to friends."
"That wasn't your fault."
"Wasn't it?" Her smile carried no warmth. "If I'd been there, maybe she would have left earlier. Maybe we'd have taken a different route. Maybe the timing would have been different enough to matter."
Ben recognized the shape of her guilt—the endless spiral of what-if scenarios that followed any tragedy, the desperate need to find some variable you could have controlled that might have changed the outcome. It was a pain he understood intimately, even if the details of his own story were complicated by the impossibility of his situation.
"How do you carry it?" he asked.
"Carefully. Like handling explosives." Helena picked up her pen again, rolling it between fingers that trembled almost imperceptibly. "Some days I manage. Some days it carries me."
They sat in comfortable silence for a moment, two people who'd found an unexpected commonality in shared damage. Around them, the coffee shop hummed with the ordinary conversations of people whose biggest concerns were work deadlines and weekend plans—a normalcy that felt foreign to both of them.
"Can I ask you something?" Helena said.
"Sure."
"The way you flinched when those sirens went past outside—that's not just about a building collapse, is it? There's something else."
Too observant. Much too observant.
"When you've been that close to dying, you develop a healthy respect for the sounds that usually mean someone else is about to have the worst day of their life."
Helena nodded with the understanding of someone who'd learned the same lesson through different circumstances. "It changes how you see the world. Makes you realize how thin the line is between normal and catastrophe."
"And how quickly everything you think you can count on can disappear."
"Exactly."
Ben's phone buzzed with a text message—Marcus asking about tomorrow's class schedule. The interruption broke the strange intimacy that had developed between them, returning them to the reality of being strangers sharing coffee instead of damaged souls recognizing each other across a crowded room.
"I should go," Ben said, standing. "But thank you. For the conversation. It's been a while since I talked to someone who understood."
Helena pulled a business card from her purse, writing her personal number on the back with precise handwriting. "Helena Bertinelli. And if you ever want to continue this discussion somewhere that serves better coffee..."
Ben accepted the card, noting her name and trying not to react to the recognition. In a few months, Helena Bertinelli would become the Huntress, consumed by vengeance against her father's criminal empire. But right now, she was just a woman carrying grief that matched his own.
"Ben Hale," he said, offering his number in return. "And I'd like that."
POV: Helena
Walking to her car through the coffee shop's parking lot, Helena found herself thinking about the gym teacher who'd somehow managed to see through her carefully constructed defenses to the grief she thought she'd hidden better.
Ben Hale was dangerous. Not in the obvious way—not like the men who worked for her father or the rivals who circled their family's business like sharks sensing blood. But dangerous in a way that threatened the careful walls she'd built around her pain, the controlled fury that had become her only reliable source of strength.
He moved like violence was a language he spoke fluently but preferred not to use. His eyes tracked threats with the automatic awareness of someone who'd learned that safety was always temporary and usually illusory. And when he'd talked about the children he couldn't save, she'd heard the particular note of self-recrimination that only came from believing you'd failed people who'd depended on you.
"He's either incredibly broken or incredibly dangerous. Possibly both. In my world, that usually means someone to avoid or eliminate. But when he looked at me, he didn't see Frank Bertinelli's daughter or a potential asset or a woman to be conquered. He saw someone carrying the same weight he was."
Helena started her car and sat for a moment in the parking lot, processing an encounter that had left her unsettled in ways she didn't entirely understand. Her life had become focused on a single goal: destroying the men who'd killed her mother, dismantling the corruption that had made her family's criminal empire possible, finding some way to balance scales that had been weighted against justice for far too long.
But talking to Ben had reminded her that life existed beyond vengeance. That there were people in the world who understood loss without trying to fix it, who recognized damage without offering false comfort. The realization should have been comforting.
Instead, it felt like a threat to the carefully maintained rage that had become her only source of purpose.
"I can't afford distractions. Not now, when I'm so close to being ready. But maybe... maybe one cup of coffee with someone who understands wouldn't hurt. Maybe having one conversation that isn't about death and revenge wouldn't make me weak."
Helena pulled out of the parking lot and drove through Starling City's evening traffic, but her mind remained fixed on dark eyes that had seen too much and a voice that carried grief like a familiar weight. Ben Hale was a complication she didn't need in a life already balanced on the knife's edge between justice and vengeance.
But complications, she was beginning to realize, weren't always unwelcome.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
Can't wait for the next chapter of [ Arrowverse: The Survivor's ]?
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them (20+ chapters ahead!). No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1