Chapter 5: The Penny Paradox
Two months into my new existence, Leonard Hofstadter did something that should have been perfectly normal but felt like stepping into a minefield: he invited me to lunch at the Cheesecake Factory.
"Come on," he said, browsing through my latest shipment of graphic novels. "You've been working non-stop since the shop took off. When's the last time you actually left this place for something other than sleep?"
I couldn't tell him the truth—that leaving the shop meant venturing into the wider world where my foreknowledge became both more powerful and more dangerous. In here, surrounded by comics and familiar faces, I could maintain the illusion of being just Stuart Bloom, lucky comic shop owner. Out there, I risked running into more pieces of the puzzle that was my impossible life.
"I don't know," I hedged. "The lunch rush is pretty busy, and I've got that shipment of—"
"Stuart." Leonard's voice carried a tone I recognized from the show—the patient but firm approach he used when Sheldon was being particularly difficult. "You're making good money now. Hire someone to watch the shop for two hours."
Twenty minutes later, I found myself walking through the doors of the Cheesecake Factory, my heart hammering against my ribs. The restaurant looked exactly as I remembered from countless episodes—overly ornate décor, impossible menu size, and bustling with the kind of controlled chaos that comes from perpetually understaffed California dining.
And there she was.
Penny moved through the restaurant with the practiced grace of someone who'd been waiting tables longer than she cared to admit. Her blonde hair caught the afternoon light streaming through the windows, and when she laughed at something a customer said, the sound was more genuine and musical than any television speaker had ever conveyed.
"She's real," the thought hit me like a physical blow. "Not an actress playing a character. Not a collection of scripted lines and predetermined character beats. She's an actual person with hopes and dreams and fears that I have no right to know."
My Memory power stirred unwillingly, flooding my consciousness with details I desperately didn't want to possess. Her failed relationship with Zack, the recurring humiliation of auditions that went nowhere, her eventual career pivot to pharmaceutical sales, her complicated romantic history that would eventually lead to marriage with the man sitting across from me.
"Stuart?" Leonard's voice seemed to come from underwater. "You okay? You look like you've seen a ghost."
More like I'm the ghost, I thought. A dead man wearing someone else's life, carrying knowledge I never should have received.
"Yeah, just... it's been a long week. Sorry."
Penny appeared at our table with the sudden materialization of a skilled server, order pad in hand and a smile that was professional but not unkind. "Hey, Leonard! How's the physics business?"
"Can't complain. The particles are cooperating today." Leonard's response carried the easy familiarity of regular customer and friendly server. "Penny, I'd like you to meet Stuart Bloom. He owns that comic book shop I mentioned."
"Oh right!" Penny's attention shifted to me, and I felt the full weight of actually being seen by someone I'd only known as a fictional construct. "The one with all the good luck lately. Leonard says you've been making some pretty impressive business moves."
"Just getting by," I managed, forcing myself to maintain eye contact despite the ethical vertigo threatening to overwhelm me. Every word felt like a lie, every smile like a manipulation, because I knew things about her that she hadn't chosen to share.
But then something unexpected happened. Instead of the dismissive politeness I remembered from early episodes, or the slightly patronizing kindness she sometimes showed to her nerdy neighbors, Penny actually seemed interested in talking to me.
"You know, it's refreshing to meet someone from that world who doesn't make me feel stupid for not knowing the difference between Marvel and DC," she said, sliding into the booth's empty space with practiced ease. "Most comic book guys either quiz me like I'm trying to join their secret club, or they explain everything like I'm five years old."
"Well," I said, surprising myself with how natural my voice sounded, "both approaches miss the point. Comics are just another way of telling stories. You don't need to memorize publication dates to appreciate good storytelling."
Penny's smile shifted from professional to genuine. "Exactly! I mean, I love a good story whether it's in a book, a movie, or apparently in a comic book. But some guys act like there's a membership fee to enjoy entertainment."
Leonard watched our interaction with the barely concealed fascination of a scientist observing an unexpected chemical reaction. I could practically see him taking mental notes about social dynamics and cross-cultural communication patterns.
As Penny took our orders and moved on to other tables, I found myself caught in an internal spiral that had nothing to do with my void-touched powers and everything to do with simple human empathy.
"She's not a character whose story I know. She's a person whose privacy I've invaded without permission. How do I interact authentically when every conversation is tainted by information she never chose to give me?"
The lunch passed in a blur of small talk and growing discomfort. Leonard filled the silence with updates about his research, but I found myself watching Penny move through the restaurant, serving other customers, laughing at their jokes, dealing with the small frustrations that came with food service work. Every gesture, every expression felt like a violation of her autonomy simply because I knew how her story was supposed to unfold.
We were finishing our food when she returned to check on us, and Leonard made the casual comment that would change everything.
"Stuart's shop is actually pretty interesting," he told her. "It's got this great atmosphere—not just retail space, but like a community hub for people who are passionate about storytelling and pop culture."
Penny's attention shifted back to me, and I caught something in her eyes that I hadn't expected—genuine curiosity. "Really? You know what, I'd like to see it sometime. I'm always curious about Leonard's world, but usually when I hang out with you guys it's all theoretical physics and engineering jokes that go over my head. A comic shop sounds more accessible."
The invitation hung in the air between us, and I realized this was a crucial moment. I could deflect, keep her at arm's length, maintain the professional distance that might preserve some semblance of ethical clarity. Or I could treat her like the real person she was and accept that my foreknowledge was a burden I'd have to carry, not something that should dictate her choices.
"I'd like that," I said, meaning it despite my complications. "No pressure to buy anything or pretend to be interested in stuff that doesn't appeal to you. Just... come check it out whenever you want."
POV Shift: Penny
Walking back to the kitchen after taking their order, Penny found herself thinking about the comic book guy in ways she hadn't expected. Stuart—that was his name—wasn't what she'd imagined when Leonard mentioned his friend who owned a shop.
For one thing, he'd looked at her. Actually looked at her, with the kind of eye contact that suggested he saw a person rather than a walking stereotype. Most guys either stared at her chest or avoided looking at her entirely, as if direct eye contact might turn them to stone. Stuart had done neither—just maintained normal, comfortable human interaction.
For another, he hadn't tried to impress her with obscure knowledge or talk down to her about subjects she didn't understand. When she'd mentioned feeling excluded from comic book culture, he'd nodded like that made perfect sense rather than launching into a lecture about why she was wrong.
"There's something different about him," she thought, refilling water glasses on autopilot. "Like he's seen things that make him take people seriously."
She'd dated enough guys to recognize the warning signs of various personality types. The ones who collected women like trophies. The ones who needed constant validation. The ones who saw her as either an intellectual inferior or a sexual object, with no middle ground for actual friendship.
Stuart had felt like none of those categories. If anything, there was something almost sad in his eyes—not self-pity, but the kind of deep tiredness that came from carrying weight other people couldn't see.
"Maybe that's why Leonard likes him. Leonard's got that same quality sometimes, like he's thinking about problems that are too big to solve."
The idea of visiting a comic book shop had come out of nowhere, an impulse decision that surprised her as much as it seemed to surprise Stuart. But she found herself genuinely curious about this space that Leonard described as special, this business that Stuart had apparently transformed from failure to success through sheer intuition.
"Plus," she admitted to herself, "it might be nice to understand more about what Leonard and his friends are passionate about. I love them, but sometimes I feel like I'm watching their conversations from outside a window."
There was something else, though—something she couldn't quite articulate. When Stuart had agreed to let her visit the shop, his acceptance had seemed genuine rather than desperately grateful. Like he actually wanted her company rather than just being thrilled that a woman was paying attention to him.
"When's the last time I met a guy who seemed comfortable with himself?" The question followed her through the rest of her shift, accompanied by the memory of eyes that seemed older than their owner's face should allow.
POV Return: Stuart
Walking back to the shop after lunch, I felt like I was carrying a bomb that could explode at any moment. The ethical implications of my situation with Penny were staggering, and I couldn't see any clear path through the minefield I'd created simply by existing in this timeline.
I knew she would date a series of increasingly inappropriate men over the next few years. I knew about her struggles with acting, her eventual career change, her complex relationship with financial stability. I knew she would marry Leonard eventually, after years of on-again, off-again romantic drama that would define both their character arcs.
Should I try to help her avoid the bad relationships? Warn her about career choices that wouldn't pan out? Use my foreknowledge to smooth the path toward her eventual happiness?
Every option felt like a violation of her agency. If I helped her too much, I'd be robbing her of the experiences that would shape her into the person Leonard would fall in love with. If I helped her too little, I'd be passively allowing suffering I could prevent.
The Memory power stirred as I wrestled with these questions, sending sharp spikes of pain through my skull. I recognized the warning—this was what happened when I tried to think too deeply about changing major timeline events. The void had given me knowledge, but it came with constraints I was still learning to understand.
"Maybe the answer isn't about changing anything," I realized as I unlocked the shop's front door. "Maybe it's about treating her like any other person I care about—with respect, honesty within reasonable limits, and the kind of friendship that doesn't require ulterior motives."
The thought brought a measure of peace, but it also highlighted the fundamental loneliness of my situation. I could be genuinely kind to Penny, authentically supportive of her goals, truly interested in her well-being. But I could never share the real source of my insights, never explain why I sometimes seemed to understand her better than I should, never reveal the weight of future knowledge that colored every interaction.
"This is the price of the void's gifts," I thought, settling behind my counter and watching the afternoon light stream through the shop windows. "Power comes with isolation. Knowledge comes with responsibility. Success comes with secrets that can never be shared."
Tomorrow, Penny would visit my shop. She would step into the space I'd created with supernatural advantages and borrowed knowledge, and I would have to navigate the interaction without letting any of the impossible truth slip through.
But tonight, I allowed myself to feel something approaching hope. Not because I could change her timeline or fix her problems, but because maybe—just maybe—I could offer the kind of authentic friendship that required nothing more than seeing each other as real people deserving of respect.
Even if one of those people was carrying the weight of an impossible secret that could never be shared.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0