Chapter 17: Penny's Confusion
POV: Penny
Penny Hofstadter—well, not yet Hofstadter, just Penny dating Leonard Hofstadter—sat across from her boyfriend at a cozy Italian restaurant, trying to focus on his animated explanation of some breakthrough in experimental physics while her mind kept drifting to thoughts that made her feel guilty and confused.
"So then I realized the particle beam was creating interference patterns that actually supported my initial hypothesis about quantum entanglement," Leonard was saying, his eyes bright with the enthusiasm that had first attracted her to him. "It's the kind of discovery that could reshape how we understand—"
"Remember when Stuart mentioned that restaurant in Little Tokyo?" Penny interrupted, then immediately froze as she realized what she'd just said.
Leonard's face fell like a deflated balloon. "Stuart?"
"I mean," Penny stammered, heat rising to her cheeks, "when we were all talking about places to eat, and Stuart suggested... why am I thinking about Stuart right now?"
"I don't know," Leonard said quietly. "Why are you thinking about Stuart right now?"
"Good question," Penny thought, taking a large gulp of wine to buy herself time. "Why am I thinking about Stuart when I'm supposed to be on a date with my boyfriend?"
The honest answer was that she'd been thinking about Stuart Bloom constantly for the past two weeks, ever since that conversation about the housing market when he'd seemed genuinely concerned about everyone's financial well-being. There was something about the way he'd tried to warn them—not condescending or lecture-y like most smart guys she knew, but like someone who actually cared about protecting the people he loved.
"Sorry," she said, reaching across the table to squeeze Leonard's hand. "I don't know where that came from. You were telling me about your quantum thing."
Leonard smiled, but it didn't quite reach his eyes. "It's okay. Stuart's been... prominent lately. With the shop success and the Summer Glau thing and whatever consulting work he's doing now. Hard not to think about him."
"The Summer Glau thing." Even thinking about Stuart's relationship with the gorgeous actress made something twist uncomfortably in Penny's stomach. Which was ridiculous, because she was dating Leonard, and Stuart was clearly happy with Summer, and everyone was where they were supposed to be.
Except Penny couldn't stop comparing the two men, and Leonard kept coming up short in ways that made her feel terrible about herself.
Leonard was sweet, considerate, eager to please her in every possible way. He laughed at her jokes even when they weren't that funny, agreed with her opinions even when she suspected he didn't share them, and generally treated her like a goddess who could do no wrong.
Stuart, on the other hand, actually talked to her. Like she was a person with thoughts worth hearing, opinions worth considering, experiences worth learning about. When she'd mentioned struggling with auditions, he hadn't tried to fix her career or offer hollow reassurances. He'd just listened, asked thoughtful questions, and shared a story about his own failures that had made her feel less alone.
"Leonard worships me," Penny realized as her boyfriend continued his enthusiastic explanation of particle physics. "Stuart sees me. There's a difference."
The thought was immediately followed by a wave of guilt. Leonard was a good man who cared about her deeply. Stuart was dating a famous actress and had never shown any romantic interest in her beyond friendship. Whatever she was feeling was probably just grass-is-greener syndrome combined with the natural appeal of someone who seemed unattainable.
"I need to talk to another woman about this," Penny decided. "Before I do something stupid that hurts everyone involved."
Two days later, Penny found herself sitting across from Bernadette Rostenkowski at a coffee shop near the university, grateful to have found someone who might understand the complexity of dating within their weird little social group.
Bernadette was Howard's new girlfriend—a tiny microbiologist with a voice like Betty Boop and the sharp intelligence that seemed to be a prerequisite for entry into their circle of friends. They'd met at Stuart's shop during one of the gaming nights, bonded over being the "normal" women in a group of brilliant weirdos, and had been gradually building a friendship based on mutual appreciation for both science and sanity.
"Okay," Penny said after they'd gotten their drinks and claimed a corner table, "I need to talk to someone about something, and you're the only person I know who might understand without judging me."
"This sounds juicy," Bernadette said with obvious interest. "Spill."
"I think I might have feelings for Stuart."
Bernadette's eyebrows shot up. "Stuart? As in, Stuart Bloom? The guy you're not dating because you're dating Leonard?"
"That Stuart," Penny confirmed miserably. "And yes, I know how messed up that sounds."
"Okay, let's unpack this," Bernadette said with the systematic approach of someone trained in laboratory analysis. "What kind of feelings are we talking about? Friendship feelings? Physical attraction? Emotional connection? All of the above?"
"All of the above," Penny admitted. "Which is why I feel like a horrible person."
"You're not a horrible person," Bernadette said firmly. "You're a human being with complicated emotions in a complicated situation. Now tell me what's making you feel this way about Stuart."
Penny stared into her latte, trying to articulate feelings she'd been avoiding examining too closely. "It's everything about him lately. The confidence without arrogance, the success without showing off, the way he knows things without making other people feel stupid. When I talk to Stuart, I feel like he actually hears what I'm saying instead of just waiting for his turn to talk."
"And with Leonard?"
"Leonard's wonderful," Penny said quickly. "He's sweet and smart and he clearly adores me. But sometimes I feel like he's in love with some idealized version of me that doesn't actually exist. Like he's afraid that if he disagrees with me or challenges me, I'll disappear."
Bernadette nodded thoughtfully. "I see the appeal of both approaches. But you know Stuart's dating Summer Glau, right? Like, the actual famous actress?"
"I know," Penny sighed. "Which makes this even more ridiculous. I'm sitting here having feelings about a guy who's completely out of my league and unavailable, while dating a guy who thinks I hung the moon."
"Can I tell you something?" Bernadette asked. "About how Howard and I got together?"
"Please."
"I met Howard at Stuart's shop, and he was doing his usual routine—trying way too hard to impress me with pickup lines and demonstrations of his intelligence. It was painful to watch. But then Stuart pulled him aside and had this conversation with him about treating women like actual people instead of conquest targets."
Bernadette leaned forward, her expression serious. "The next time I saw Howard, he was different. Still awkward, still Howard, but genuine. He asked what I was interested in instead of telling me what he thought I should find impressive. He listened to my answers instead of planning his next joke. Stuart's advice basically saved Howard from himself."
"So you think Stuart's just... good at relationships?"
"I think Stuart understands something that a lot of guys don't," Bernadette said. "That authenticity is more attractive than performance. That treating someone with genuine respect and interest is better than putting them on a pedestal or trying to dazzle them with accomplishments."
Penny absorbed this, recognizing the truth in Bernadette's observation. "So what am I supposed to do with these feelings?"
"Well," Bernadette said carefully, "first you need to figure out what you actually want. Are you attracted to Stuart specifically, or are you attracted to the way he makes you feel about yourself? Because those are two different things."
"What's the difference?"
"The difference is whether you want Stuart, or whether you want Leonard to treat you the way Stuart treats you."
The distinction hit Penny like a physical blow. Was she developing feelings for Stuart himself, or was she just frustrated with the dynamics of her relationship with Leonard?
"How do I figure that out?"
"Spend some time with Stuart," Bernadette suggested. "Not in a romantic way, just as friends. See if the attraction is about him specifically or about the way he interacts with people in general. And maybe talk to Leonard about what you need from him emotionally. He's a smart guy—he might be able to adjust his approach if he understands what you're looking for."
"And if it turns out I do have real feelings for Stuart?"
Bernadette's expression became more serious. "Then you need to be honest with everyone involved, including yourself. But remember that Stuart chose Summer, and you chose Leonard. Sometimes feelings happen that we can't act on without causing a lot of pain to people we care about."
"Great," Penny thought. "So either I'm just confused about what I want from Leonard, or I'm in love with someone I can't have while dating someone who deserves better. Either way, this is a mess."
The next afternoon, Penny found herself standing outside Stuart's comic shop, ostensibly there to browse but really there to test Bernadette's theory about whether her feelings were about Stuart specifically or just about feeling truly seen by another person.
The shop was busy with its usual afternoon crowd, but Stuart spotted her immediately and waved her over with the kind of genuine smile that made her stomach flip in ways that probably answered her question right there.
"Penny! Good to see you. Looking for anything specific, or just browsing?"
"Just browsing," she said, hoping her voice sounded more casual than she felt. "Maybe something new to read."
For the next twenty minutes, Stuart guided her through various options, asking about her preferences, making recommendations based on what she actually enjoyed rather than what he thought she should like. When she mentioned loving stories about people overcoming difficult circumstances, he pulled out a graphic memoir about a woman who'd built a successful business after escaping an abusive relationship.
"This one's incredible," he said, handing her the book. "It's honest about how hard recovery is, but also inspiring about how much resilience people can find when they need it."
The recommendation was perfect—thoughtful, personal, chosen specifically for her interests rather than to impress her with his knowledge. And when she laughed at one of his stories about a customer who'd tried to return a comic because "the superhero made unrealistic life choices," Stuart's face lit up with the kind of pleasure that came from genuinely enjoying someone's company.
"This is bad," Penny realized, watching Stuart interact with other customers with the same authentic interest he'd shown her. "This isn't about wanting Leonard to treat me differently. This is about wanting to be with Stuart instead of Leonard."
"I should probably get going," she said, purchasing the graphic novel and preparing to flee before she did something irresponsible.
"Leonard's lucky to have you," Stuart called after her as she headed for the door.
The comment should have felt like a friend-zone dismissal, but something in his tone made it sound almost wistful. Penny paused at the door, looking back at him over her shoulder.
"Is he?" she asked quietly.
Stuart's expression became more serious, and for a moment she thought he might say something that would change everything between them. Instead, he smiled—sad but genuine.
"Yeah," he said. "He really is."
Walking home, Penny felt the weight of her situation settling around her like a heavy coat. She was definitely, unquestionably attracted to Stuart Bloom in ways that went far beyond friendship. But Stuart was maintaining appropriate boundaries, Leonard deserved honesty and respect, and acting on her feelings would hurt everyone involved.
"Sometimes," she thought, "the right thing and the thing you want are completely different things. And sometimes being a good person means living with the difference."
But knowing what she should do and being able to stop thinking about Stuart's "old eyes" and wistful smile were proving to be entirely separate challenges.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($5): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($8): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0