Cherreads

Chapter 69 - Chapter 63 — What We Haven’t Said Yet

The night felt unusually still when she returned to her apartment. Even after she closed the door behind her, the quiet clung to the walls like something alive. It wasn't uncomfortable—just expectant, as if the silence was waiting for her to fill it with whatever emotions she hadn't dared to say out loud.

She set her phone down on the table. No messages from him yet.

That alone was strange.

Even during their brief arguments, their unspoken distance, their stubborn silences, he always sent something. A simple "made it home?" or "text me when you're safe." But tonight, nothing.

She pulled her knees up on the couch, hugging herself.

"Maybe he's busy," she murmured to no one. "Maybe I shouldn't overthink."

Except she was overthinking.

Ever since that moment earlier—when he looked at her as if he was finally ready to say something he'd been swallowing for too long—her heart hadn't stopped racing.

She reached for her phone again, hesitated, and finally typed:

"Are you home?"

Ten seconds.

Thirty seconds.

A full minute.

No reply.

She set the phone down with a frustrated exhale, sinking deeper into the couch cushions. She hated how easily her emotions tangled when it came to him. She hated how a single unread message could twist something sharp inside her chest.

She stood up abruptly, pacing.

Maybe she should just go to sleep.

Maybe she should distract herself with schoolwork.

Maybe she should stop checking her phone like someone waiting for a miracle.

But then—

A soft knock broke the silence.

Her breath vanished.

She wasn't expecting anyone.

Unless—

Her feet carried her to the door before her mind caught up. Her hand trembled slightly as she turned the knob.

He stood there.

Button-down shirt slightly wrinkled.

Hair still damp from a shower.

Tie stuffed loosely in his pocket instead of around his collar.

And eyes—deep, unreadable, but undeniably drawn to her.

"You didn't answer my message…" she whispered.

He shook his head faintly. "I know."

"Then why—?"

"I thought I should come instead."

Just like that, everything inside her tightened.

This wasn't the usual "I was passing by" or "I wanted to make sure you were okay."

His expression carried something heavier. Something real.

She stepped aside silently. He walked in, taking slow breaths as though steadying himself. When she closed the door, the faint click felt louder than it should.

He spoke first.

"I didn't text back because… I wasn't sure words were enough."

Her heart stumbled. "Enough for what?"

He looked at her then—really looked.

Not with caution.

Not with restraint.

But with a kind of sincerity that made her pulse jump painfully.

"Earlier," he said, voice deep and low, "when I almost said something… I didn't stop because I didn't mean it. I stopped because it felt too important to say casually."

Her lips parted, but no sound came out.

"I don't want to confuse you," he continued. "I don't want to rush you. And I don't want you thinking I'm playing with your feelings."

"You're not," she whispered instantly.

He smiled—slow, pained, relieved.

"I'm glad you believe that."

A beat.

"But I need you to understand what you're doing to me."

Those words sent heat rushing to her face.

He took a step closer.

"You come into my life with this… brightness," he said. "You look at me like I'm someone better than I really am. And every day, it gets harder to pretend I don't feel something for you."

Her chest tightened.

She couldn't breathe.

Couldn't look away.

He didn't touch her.

Didn't reach out.

He simply continued, voice rougher now:

"I didn't text because I knew I'd say too much. And I didn't want to say it through a screen."

Silence swept between them—warm, fragile, electric.

She finally found her voice. "What did you want to say?"

His breath caught.

Then, quietly, "That you're not the only one feeling afraid of losing someone."

Her heartbeat slammed against her ribs.

"And," he added, taking another small step toward her, "that I'm tired of pretending I don't miss you every second we're apart."

Her knees weakened.

He stopped just close enough that she could feel the heat of him, but not so close that they touched.

"Tell me if I'm wrong," he murmured.

"You're not," she breathed.

A soft exhale left him—half relief, half something deeper.

He lifted a hand as if wanting to touch her cheek, then dropped it abruptly, forcing restraint into place.

"I don't want to cross any lines you're not ready for."

She swallowed. "What if I'm ready?"

He froze.

For the first time that night, he looked genuinely shaken—like she'd cracked open something he'd been burying for far too long.

"Then," he said slowly, "I need to hear you say what you want."

She stepped closer, closing the distance he refused to cross.

"I want you to stay," she whispered.

"And I want you to stop acting like you don't feel the same."

His control broke—just a little.

He leaned in, forehead brushing hers, breath warm against her mouth, eyes dark with emotion he couldn't hide anymore.

"I feel everything," he said. "Too much."

"Then stop fighting it."

His lips nearly touched hers—

But he stopped just in time, jaw tense.

"You matter to me," he whispered. "More than you know."

Her hands trembled as she reached up, fingers brushing his shirt lightly.

"And you matter to me."

His eyes closed.

And in that fragile, breathless space between them, something finally shifted—something neither of them could undo.

More Chapters