Chapter 42: The Proposal part2
Saturday arrived with unseasonable warmth that turned February snow to slush.
Ben woke at dawn, nerves screaming. His Danger Intuition stayed silent—rare enough that the absence felt ominous. No warnings. No threats. Just clean anticipation of a moment that would define his future in this universe.
He showered, dressed carefully. Jeans and flannel—nothing fancy because Fiona would find fancy suspicious. Normal clothes for an abnormal day.
The ring box burned in his pocket.
At 2 PM, Lip texted: Fiona incoming. We're ready.
Ben walked to the Gallagher house. His heart hammered against ribs, palms sweating despite the cold. MacGyver Mind tried offering speech optimization, perfect phrasing, guaranteed emotional impact.
He shoved the power down. This needed to be real, not crafted. Honest, not manipulated.
The backyard looked different. Someone had cleaned it—trash removed, snow shoveled, space cleared. V had strung lights even though it was daylight. The kids clustered near the fence, vibrating with barely contained excitement.
Debbie saw him first. "Ben! Is it time?"
"Almost. Where's Fiona?"
"Lip's bringing her. Two minutes." Debbie bounced on her toes. "This is so romantic! Like in movies!"
Carl rolled his eyes. "It's just a proposal."
"It's Fiona getting engaged, dumbass. That's huge."
Ian emerged from the house with drinks nobody would touch, his face carrying that particular anxiety about family moments going wrong. "Everyone ready? We're really doing this?"
"We're really doing this," Ben confirmed.
Liam, age two and understanding nothing, toddled over and hugged Ben's leg. "Ben!"
The simple affection nearly broke him. This kid had no idea what was happening, just knew Ben showed up regularly and that meant safety.
That's what I'm offering Fiona. Showing up. Consistently. Forever.
The back door opened. Lip appeared, followed by Fiona wearing confusion and the beginnings of realization.
"What..." Fiona stopped. Looked at the gathered family, the cleaned yard, the lights V insisted on, Ben standing nervous and exposed in the center of it all. "Oh god."
"Surprise?" Ben tried.
Fiona's hands started shaking. Not from cold—from emotion that looked like terror and hope mixed together.
V was already crying. Kevin had his phone out, recording everything. The kids watched with breathless attention.
Ben's Danger Intuition stayed silent. This was right. Safe. Perfect.
"Fiona," Ben started. His voice cracked. He cleared his throat, tried again. "Three months ago you showed up at my garage asking if we could talk. I thought you were going to tell me Steve was back, that you'd chosen him, that I'd lost my chance."
"Instead you kissed me," Fiona whispered.
"Instead you kissed me. And my whole life changed." Ben pulled out the ring box. Debbie gasped. V sobbed louder. "You gave me a home when I had nothing. Made me family when I was alone. Showed me what love actually means when I thought I'd never have it."
Fiona's eyes filled with tears. "Ben—"
"Let me finish. Please." His hands trembled holding the box. "I want forever with you. Raising these kids together, building a life, facing whatever comes next as partners instead of two people fighting separately. You deserve someone who shows up every single day, who doesn't run when things get hard, who chooses you consistently instead of when it's convenient."
"You're that person," Fiona said, barely audible.
"I'm trying to be. Every day I try." Ben opened the box. The diamond caught sunlight, throwing tiny rainbows across melting snow. "Will you marry me?"
Fiona didn't answer immediately. She stared at the ring, at Ben, at her gathered family watching the moment with held breath.
"Yes," she said finally. "God, yes."
The response came before Ben fully finished asking. Fiona closed the distance, practically tackled him, laughing and crying simultaneously. The ring box fell. Ian caught it—good reflexes preventing disaster.
Fiona kissed Ben like she was drowning and he was air. Hard, desperate, perfect. When they broke apart she was shaking, tears streaming, smiling so wide it had to hurt.
"Yes," she repeated. "In case that wasn't clear. Yes, I'll marry you, you stupid wonderful man."
The family erupted. Debbie screamed. V sobbed incoherently. Kevin cheered while filming. Carl looked uncomfortable but pleased. Liam clapped without understanding why.
Ian handed Ben the ring box. "You dropped this."
Ben took the ring out with fingers that barely worked. Fiona held out her left hand, steadier than his despite the emotion. He slid the ring on. It fit perfectly—MacGyver Mind's measurements had been exact.
Fiona stared at her hand, at the ring that made everything official. "It's perfect. How did you know my size?"
"Measured while you were sleeping."
"That's creepy."
"That's romantic!" Debbie insisted.
Frank appeared in the doorway, drunk before 3 PM. "Did I miss the show?"
"Dad, Ben proposed. Fiona said yes." Lip's tone suggested Frank's presence was unwelcome but inevitable.
"Well shit. Congratulations." Frank raised his beer. "Marriage is a beautiful institution that will make you both miserable. Enjoy the honeymoon phase while it lasts."
"Get out, Frank," Fiona said without heat.
"Going, going." Frank retreated inside, taking his cynicism with him.
V descended on Fiona, hugging her hard enough to crack ribs. "You're engaged! My best friend is getting married!"
"V, can't breathe—"
"I don't care! This is amazing! We're planning everything together. Colors, flowers, dress, all of it!" V finally released Fiona, turned to Ben. "You better treat her right or I'll kill you."
"Noted."
Kevin congratulated Ben with a back-slap that nearly knocked him over. "Welcome to the engaged life, man. It's terrifying and great in equal measure."
The kids surrounded Fiona, all talking at once. Debbie wanted to plan the wedding immediately. Carl offered to handle security. Ian suggested simple and cheap. Liam just wanted attention.
Fiona looked overwhelmed, happy, terrified. She kept touching the ring like confirming it was real.
Ben watched his new fiancée surrounded by family, overwhelmed by love and attention and possibility. This was what he'd offered—not just marriage but partnership, not just commitment but family, not just love but showing up every single day regardless of chaos.
She said yes. Fiona Gallagher said yes to marrying me. To building a life together. To facing whatever comes next as partners.
The relief was physical. Ben's knees felt weak. His Danger Intuition stayed silent, confirming this was right, safe, exactly what needed to happen.
Lip appeared at Ben's elbow. "Congratulations. You officially can't back out now."
"Wasn't planning to."
"Good. Because if you hurt her after this, I won't just hurt you back. I'll destroy you." Lip smiled like he meant it. "But I don't think I'll need to. You actually love her. It's fucking weird but it's real."
"It's real," Ben confirmed.
The afternoon dissolved into celebration. Kevin ran to the Alibi, returned with champagne that was probably stolen. They toasted in the backyard while February sun attempted warmth, family gathered around, joy and chaos mixing like they always did in Gallagher territory.
Fiona kept glancing at Ben, at her ring, at her family, like she couldn't believe this was happening, that something good was actually occurring without disaster attached.
Ben knew better. His Danger Intuition showed storms approaching—Robbie, cocaine, house arrest. All the Season 2 chaos waiting on the horizon.
But tonight there was joy. Uncomplicated, hard-earned, precious joy. Tomorrow would bring planning and worry and preparation. Tonight was celebration.
That night, after the champagne ran out and the family dispersed and V finally stopped crying, Ben and Fiona lay in her bed staring at the ceiling.
"This is real, right?" Fiona whispered. "Not too fast?"
Ben found her left hand, touched the ring. "It's real. And perfect timing."
"How is three months perfect timing? We barely know each other."
Because Season 2 chaos approaches and stability needs to come first. Because I know from the show that we work eventually so why not speed the timeline. Because my transmigration gave me foreknowledge that makes normal relationship progressions irrelevant.
"Because I love you," Ben said instead. "And I'm not going anywhere. Three months or three years, that doesn't change."
Fiona turned on her side, facing him in darkness. "I'm scared."
"Of what?"
"That this is too good. That something will go wrong. That I'll ruin it by being me—chaotic, self-destructive, bad at accepting help."
Ben pulled her close. "You're also strong, loving, dedicated to your family, and capable of surviving anything. Those things matter more than your fears."
"You really believe that?"
"I really do."
She kissed him, softer than earlier, more intimate. "I love you. I don't say it enough but I do. You showed up in my life when everything was falling apart and you just... helped. Without expecting anything. Just helped."
"That's what you do for family."
"We're really doing this? Getting married?"
"We're really doing this."
Fiona stared at her ring in moonlight coming through windows. The diamond caught pale light, throwing tiny shadows across sheets. "When?"
"Whenever you want."
"Soon," she decided. "I don't need a big wedding. Just family, just us, just simple."
Ben's Danger Intuition pulsed soft warnings about summer—Robbie's approach, cocaine's shadow. They needed to be married before that hit. Formalized, committed, legally bound before chaos tested everything.
"Summer?" Ben suggested. "August maybe?"
"August works. Gives us time to plan without being ridiculous about it." Fiona smiled. "Mrs. Fiona Fisher. That sounds weird."
"You don't have to change your name."
"I might. Haven't decided yet." She yawned, exhaustion catching up with emotion. "Thank you for proposing. For loving me. For being here."
"Thank you for saying yes."
They fell asleep engaged, facing the future together, unaware of how soon that future would test them.
But tonight was perfect. Tomorrow could bring its storms. Tonight they had joy and promises and the beginning of forever.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1