Chapter 67: Billy's Redemption Moment
Max
The walk home from Steve's bunker felt longer in November cold. Strategy meetings ran late—planning the final assault, coordinating teams, preparing for tomorrow's battle.
I should have called someone for a ride. But the streets seemed empty, safe. The demo-dogs had been quiet lately, pulled back toward the source gate.
The clicking came from the storm drain.
I froze. Recognized that sound from recordings, from descriptions, from nightmares.
The creature emerged slowly. Medium-sized demo-dog, face-petals opening to taste the air. It spotted me.
Time to run.
Billy
I'd been following Max at distance for weeks. She didn't know. Would've been pissed if she found out. But Steve had recruited me, given me purpose beyond anger and self-destruction.
Protecting Max felt right. Like choosing to be someone different.
The demo-dog stalked from the drain. Max ran. The creature gave chase, faster than she was.
Not her. Not on my watch.
I charged from the shadows, tire iron in hand, screaming to draw its attention.
The creature pivoted. Saw me. Lunged.
Its claws tore through my jacket, ripped skin beneath. Pain exploded across my ribs. But I swung the tire iron, connected with its skull, bought Max seconds to escape.
"RUN!" I roared. "GET STEVE!"
The demo-dog tackled me. Face-petals opened inches from my throat. I shoved the tire iron between its teeth, held it back through pure desperation.
Just like Neil. Always something trying to kill me. Difference is, this time I'm choosing to fight for someone else.
Steve
Phase 3 senses caught the screaming three blocks away. I ran, corruption-enhanced speed making me blur through streets.
Found Billy on the ground, demo-dog on top of him, Max frozen nearby in shock.
One motion. Knife throw. Creature's head snapped back, blade through its brain. It collapsed.
Billy lay bleeding, three deep lacerations across his ribs, bite marks on his shoulder. Conscious but going into shock.
"Max, call Hopper," I commanded. Knelt beside Billy. "You saved her."
"Had to." Billy's voice came out weak. "She's... annoying. But she's mine to protect."
"You did good." I placed my hands on his wounds. "This is going to hurt."
Pain Heal activated.
Billy
Fire spread from Steve's touch. Not burning—absorbing. My pain flowing into him, wounds starting to knit.
But something else came with it. Memories. Trauma. Things I'd buried deep.
Neil's fist connecting with my jaw. "You're worthless, boy." Cigarette burns on my arms. Belt across my back. Terror becoming rage becoming violence becoming who I am.
Steve gasped. Saw it all. Every moment, every beating, every lesson in fear that Neil had taught.
"I'm sorry," Steve whispered. "I didn't know it was that bad."
The healing continued. Physical pain fading, emotional wounds laid bare.
Steve
The memories transferred through Pain Heal like poison. I'd absorbed physical suffering before, but this—this was trauma made tangible.
Felt Neil's rage. Billy's helplessness. The child learning violence was only language his father spoke. The teenager building walls of anger to survive. The young man trapped in cycle he couldn't break.
"Jesus Christ, Billy," I breathed. Wounds closing, scars forming. "You've been fighting your whole life."
"Yeah." His voice cracked. "Neil made me into this. Angry. Violent. Afraid of everything. I don't want to be him. But I don't know how to be anyone else."
I finished healing, sat back. Corruption pulsed darker from the absorbed trauma.
"You just saved Max. Took hits meant for her. Fought a monster to give her time to escape." I met his eyes. "That's not Neil. That's you. The real you."
"How do you know there's a real me under all this?"
"Because I just felt your mind. Felt everything." I touched my chest where his trauma sat heavy. "Neil created the anger. But the choice to protect Max? That's all you. That's who you really are."
Max
Billy sat up slowly, healed but shaking. He looked at me—really looked, not the aggressive glare, not the dismissive sneer.
"You okay?" he asked.
"I'm fine. You saved me."
"Yeah. Well. Someone has to keep you from doing stupid shit."
"Billy—"
"Don't. Just..." He struggled with words. "I'm trying to be better. Steve's helping me see I can be someone different. But it's hard. I don't know how to be soft or kind or whatever. I just know how to be angry."
I hugged him. He stiffened, unfamiliar with affection that didn't hurt. Then slowly, hesitantly, hugged back.
"Thank you," I whispered. "For choosing me over running."
"Always will. You're my sister. Pain in the ass, but mine."
"Stepsis—"
"Sister. Don't care what paperwork says." His voice held certainty. "You're family. I protect family."
Steve
Hopper arrived with medical supplies we didn't need. Billy's wounds were healed, just fresh scars remaining.
"What happened?" Hopper demanded.
"Demo-dog attacked Max. Billy intervened." I helped Billy stand. "He saved her life."
Hopper studied Billy—bloody, exhausted, protective. "Good work, kid."
Billy nodded, uncomfortable with praise. I understood. Neil never gave praise, only punishment. Positive reinforcement was foreign language.
"Billy," I said quietly. "You asked me to help you be different. I will. But you're already doing it. Every time you choose to protect instead of hurt, every time you fight for someone else, you're becoming the person Neil couldn't make you."
"What if I fail? What if I hurt her anyway?"
"Then you apologize and try again. That's what Neil never did. That's the difference." I squeezed his shoulder. "Redemption isn't one big moment. It's a thousand small choices. You just made one. Keep making them."
Billy looked at Max, who smiled at him tentatively. Something in his face shifted—walls lowering, walls he'd built to survive childhood.
"Okay," he said. "I'll try."
Billy
Steve drove us home. Max fell asleep in the backseat, exhausted from fear and relief.
"You felt it," I said quietly. "Everything Neil did."
"Yeah."
"And you don't think I'm... broken? Beyond fixing?"
Steve's corruption pulsed in the dim light. "Billy, I'm literally being consumed by alien intelligence. My body is half-shadow. I fight monsters daily. 'Broken' is relative." He glanced at me. "What Neil did was unforgivable. But it doesn't define you. Not anymore. You get to choose who you become next."
"What if I don't know how?"
"Then we figure it out together. One choice at a time."
We sat in silence. Two people broken by different mechanisms, trying to become something better.
"Steve?" Billy asked. "Tomorrow's assault. Am I on the team?"
"Yeah. Assault team. You, me, Hopper, Eleven. Front lines."
"Good." Billy's hands clenched. "I want to hurt the thing that's been terrorizing this town. For Max. For everyone."
"Just don't die doing it. Max needs her big brother."
"Stepbrother."
"Brother. Don't care what paperwork says."
Billy smiled—small, genuine. First real smile I'd seen from him.
Maybe redemption was possible. Maybe people could break cycles. Maybe violence taught could become violence unlearned.
Tomorrow would test that. Tomorrow, we'd see if any of us survived our transformations.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0