Alaric's apartment was becoming a second home.
I arrived at five, still wearing my school clothes, my backpack heavy with homework I'd probably never finish. The hunter was already pacing, agitated by the information I'd shared via text.
"You made contact with Anna." He didn't phrase it as a question. "Without backup. Without consulting the rest of us."
"The opportunity presented itself." I dropped my bag by the door and moved to the window, checking the street below out of habit. "She was watching Jeremy at the Grill. I had maybe ten minutes before she left. There wasn't time for a committee meeting."
"There's always time to not get killed by a five-hundred-year-old vampire."
"She didn't try to kill me."
"This time." Alaric grabbed a bourbon bottle from his counter and poured himself a generous measure. He didn't offer me one—I was technically a minor, and he was technically a teacher. Some boundaries remained even in supernatural warfare. "What exactly did you tell her?"
"That I know about the tomb. That I'm not opposed to Pearl's release specifically. That I'm opposed to twenty-six starving vampires being unleashed on Mystic Falls."
"And she believed you?"
"She believed I was interesting enough to not kill immediately. That's a start."
Stefan arrived fifteen minutes later, looking as worn as I felt. The stress of monitoring Damon while maintaining his relationship with Elena was taking its toll.
"I've been thinking about Anna all day," he said, settling into Alaric's only comfortable chair. "She's dangerous—genuinely dangerous. But she's not evil. She just wants her mother back."
"She's not unlike Matt, actually," Alaric said, and I flinched at the comparison. "Willing to work with vampires to save family. Willing to cross lines that shouldn't be crossed."
"I was trying to save Vicki from vampires," I said quietly. "Anna is trying to free them."
"The motivation is the same. The methods are different. The scale..." Alaric shrugged. "If Pearl gets out and starts feeding, the body count could be enormous. Is one mother worth that?"
The question hung in the air, uncomfortable and unavoidable.
"Here's what I keep coming back to," I said slowly, organizing my thoughts as I spoke. "Anna's been trying to free Pearl for 145 years. She's patient, strategic, and completely committed. If we make her an enemy, she'll open that tomb anyway—just with Damon's help and no regard for collateral damage. But if we can work with her, guide the process, maybe we control the outcome."
"You want to help her open the tomb," Stefan said flatly.
"I want to help her extract Pearl without releasing everyone else. There has to be a way. A partial opening. A contained breach. Something that gives Anna what she wants without giving us a vampire army."
Alaric shook his head. "The seal is all or nothing. Emily Bennett designed it that way."
"Emily Bennett is dead. Sheila Bennett isn't." I turned to Stefan. "Could Grams modify the spell? Adjust the parameters somehow?"
"That would require her knowing the full situation. Agreeing to help free vampires. Putting herself at risk from Damon."
"Grams already knows more than she lets on. She called me 'blood child' the first time we met. She's been preparing Bonnie for something. Maybe she's been preparing for this too."
We debated for another hour, going in circles, never reaching consensus. Alaric wanted to eliminate Anna as a threat—hunter instincts that refused to trust any vampire. Stefan worried about the cascade effects of any intervention, the butterfly consequences that could make things worse. I kept pushing for negotiation, for controlled chaos, for anything that didn't end in massacre.
In the end, we agreed on nothing except continued monitoring.
"I need coffee," Alaric muttered, moving to his kitchen. "Want some?"
"Sure."
He returned with two mugs—his decent, mine slightly less terrible than the vending machine poison Bonnie and I had shared. Progress came in small increments.
"You know," Alaric said, settling back into his seat, "when I came to Mystic Falls, I thought I'd find one vampire. Kill him for what he did to Isobel. Move on with my life." He laughed bitterly. "Instead, I found a town full of monsters, a kid with blood powers, and a tomb full of starving vampires about to be unleashed. My life was simpler when I was just a grief-stricken widower."
"Was it better?"
He considered that. "No. Just simpler. Simpler isn't the same as better."
I thought about my own journey—waking up in Matt Donovan's body, discovering powers I didn't understand, building alliances, losing Vicki, fighting battles I couldn't win. My life had been simpler before the transmigration. But it had also been... less. Less meaningful. Less urgent. Less alive.
"Anna isn't evil," I said, returning to the core problem. "She's desperate. Desperation I understand. Desperation I've felt myself, watching Vicki slip away, knowing I'd try anything to save her."
"And where did that desperation get you?" Alaric asked quietly.
The question cut deeper than he knew. I'd tried everything to save Vicki—bonds, healing, bargains with Stefan. And she'd still died in my arms, a stake through her heart, her face turning gray as the vampire left her body.
"Nowhere good," I admitted. "But I'd still try again. Knowing the outcome, knowing the cost, I'd still try."
"That's the problem with desperation. It makes us stupid."
"Or brave. Depending on how it turns out."
Stefan stood, ending the conversation before it could spiral further. "I'll reach out to Anna through discrete channels. Feel her out about alternatives to a full tomb opening. If she's willing to negotiate, we negotiate. If she's not..."
"We prepare for war," Alaric finished.
"We prepare for war."
I walked home through the December darkness, my blood sense extended as far as I could push it. The streets were quiet—most people inside, preparing for Christmas, living normal lives that didn't involve vampires or tombs or alliances with monsters.
Anna wasn't evil. She was a daughter who loved her mother. Damon wasn't evil—he was a man who'd loved someone for 145 years, willing to burn the world to save her. Even the starving vampires in the tomb weren't evil by nature. They were people who'd been transformed against their will, sealed in darkness, driven mad by hunger.
None of them deserved what was coming. But none of them could be allowed to destroy Mystic Falls either.
I thought about monsters and mothers. About the line between desperation and destruction. About Vicki's face in her final moments, asking me to do what had to be done.
Some choices had no good options. Only different kinds of bad ones.
By the time I reached my trailer, I'd made a decision. Tomorrow, I'd contact Anna directly. Offer her something concrete—a plan, a partnership, a path to Pearl that didn't require massacre.
It might work. It might get me killed. But doing nothing guaranteed disaster.
I'd rather die trying than survive watching.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0