[SAMCRO Clubhouse — December 24, 2008, 6:00 PM]
The clubhouse looked different with tinsel.
Someone—probably Gemma—had transformed the usual rough space into something almost festive. Lights strung along the bar, a tree in the corner decorated with motorcycle ornaments, wreaths on doors that usually only opened for violence.
Families filled the room. Kids I'd never seen ran between tables, chasing each other while their parents pretended not to watch. Old ladies clustered near the kitchen, organizing food and gossip with equal efficiency.
"Strange, isn't it?" Sarah appeared beside me, eyes bright with the reflected lights. "Seeing this place like this."
"Strange is one word."
"What's another?"
Normal. Human. The kind of thing I didn't think I'd ever have.
"Nice."
She laughed, took my hand. "Come on. There's eggnog."
---
[SAMCRO Clubhouse — December 24, 2008, 8:00 PM]
The gift exchange happened after dinner.
Secret Santa rules, apparently a clubhouse tradition. Men who'd killed for each other passing wrapped packages with the awkward enthusiasm of fathers at a school recital.
Half-Sack got a new helmet. Chibs received a bottle of Irish whiskey that made his eyes water. Bobby unwrapped a set of vintage cooking knives and immediately started planning menus.
My package contained a leather riding jacket—higher quality than anything I owned, with the SAMCRO patch already sewn in place.
"From the table," Jax said, catching my eye across the room. "Unanimous."
Unanimous. Like the vote that made me a member. Like the vote that started the war.
This club speaks through consensus. And tonight, consensus says you belong.
"Thank you."
The words felt inadequate. But Jax nodded, understanding what couldn't be spoken.
---
[Cole's Apartment — December 24, 2008, 11:00 PM]
The private exchange happened later.
Sarah and I had left the clubhouse early—not antisocial, just ready for quiet. The apartment felt warm despite the December chill, fairy lights she'd strung creating soft shadows on the walls.
"Open yours first." She handed me a wrapped package, nervous in a way I rarely saw from her.
Inside was a leather journal, rich brown, the kind meant for years of use. On the first page, she'd written: For when you can't talk to me. I'll still be listening.
"Sarah—"
"I know you have things you can't share. Things I probably don't want to know." She met my eyes. "But you can write them. Get them out of your head. And when you're ready to talk, I'm here."
I pulled out the jewelry box before I could choke on the words stuck in my throat.
"For you."
She opened it carefully, drew in a sharp breath when she saw the pendant. Silver against velvet, the sapphire catching the light.
"Cole. It's beautiful."
"So are you." The words came out rough, honest. "You stayed. Through everything—the war, the distance, the emptiness. You stayed."
"Of course I stayed." Her eyes were wet but smiling. "I love you."
"I love you too." First time saying it without the weight of everything else pressing down. Just the truth, simple and clear. "I love you, Sarah."
She kissed me, pendant still clutched in her hand, and for a moment the world contained nothing but warmth.
---
[St. Thomas Church — December 25, 2008, 12:15 AM]
Midnight mass was Sarah's idea.
I wasn't religious—hadn't been before the transmigration, certainly wasn't after—but she'd asked, and after everything she'd given me, attending seemed a small price.
The church was old, wooden, filled with candles that made the darkness feel sacred rather than threatening. Families filled the pews, singing carols I half-remembered from another life.
Strange. Sitting here, pretending to be normal. Surrounded by people who have no idea what I've done, what I've become.
But maybe that's what churches are for. Places where everyone pretends, and the pretending somehow becomes real.
The service washed over me—prayers I didn't believe, songs I couldn't quite remember, the ritual comfort of community. I didn't find God. But I found something like peace.
Maybe that's enough.
---
[SAMCRO Clubhouse — December 25, 2008, 2:00 PM]
Christmas Day brought the families back.
Turkey and ham and too many sides to count. Kids tearing into presents that had appeared under the tree overnight. The noise and chaos of people who loved each other occupying the same space.
Bobby raised a glass at some point—I'd lost track of the toasts—and the room fell quiet.
"To the brothers we've lost. To the ones still standing. To family." He looked around the room, eyes landing on each face. "This year tested us. Took from us. But we're still here. Still together. That means something."
"To family," the room echoed.
I drank with the rest of them. Tasted the whiskey, felt the burn, watched the people around me celebrate survival.
This is family. Not blood—something else. Something forged in fire and maintained through choice.
You belong here. After everything, you belong.
Gemma caught my eye across the room. Something passed between us—acknowledgment, maybe. Gratitude. We'd never talked about Weston, about Zobelle, about what I'd done in her name. But she knew. And knowing was enough.
"Merry Christmas, Cole."
"Merry Christmas, Gemma."
She almost smiled. Almost.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes .
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!