Cherreads

Chapter 18 - I Let Him Believe I’m Still Afraid.

(Noa POV)

Fear is useful.

That's the first thing I learn once I stop drowning in it.

Elias thinks fear keeps me compliant. Keeps me predictable. Keeps me inside the lines he's drawn so carefully around my life.

He's wrong.

Fear makes me observant.

It sharpens my memory instead of blurring it. It teaches me when to speak, when to stay silent, when to look small enough to be overlooked.

So when he turns his back on me after our conversation—after I tell him maybe I remembered something he didn't know—I let my shoulders slump. I let my breath shake. I let my hands tremble just enough to sell it.

I let him believe he scared me back into place.

He doesn't look back, but I feel his attention stretch toward me like a wire pulled too tight. He's listening for movement. For resistance. For collapse.

I give him none of it.

I go to the bedroom and close the door softly behind me. Not locked. Never locked. Locked doors make him curious.

I sit on the bed and stare at my hands until my heartbeat slows.

Then I think.

Not about escape.

Not yet.

About patterns.

Elias lives by them. Trusts them. Worships them. He believes humans are systems because he is one. Every action optimized. Every emotion filtered through logic. Every mistake cataloged and corrected.

Which means if I want to survive him, I can't act randomly.

I have to become an anomaly.

I lie back on the bed and stare at the ceiling, letting my breathing even out. I replay everything—every conversation, every moment he thought I wasn't paying attention.

The way he always stands between me and doors without touching me.

The way he corrects language instead of denying accusations.

The way he never says I'm sorry, only I chose.

He doesn't regret.

He calculates.

And calculations can be disrupted.

I turn onto my side and close my eyes.

Sleep comes fast and heavy, like my body has been waiting for permission.

I dream.

Not clearly. Never clearly.

But this time, the dream doesn't dissolve when I wake up.

I'm standing in the stairwell again.

The air smells like dust and metal. The lights flicker overhead. My hands are shaking so badly I can barely hold my phone.

He's there.

Not Elias.

The other man.

His face is still wrong—blurred, like my mind refuses to finish drawing him—but I feel him. Too close. Too familiar. Too entitled.

"Please," I'm saying. I hear it now. My own voice. Not hysterical. Controlled. Measured.

I'm trying to reason with him.

That realization hurts more than the fall.

Because it means I wasn't panicking.

I was thinking.

He steps closer.

I step back.

The railing presses into my spine.

And then—

I wake up gasping, sitting bolt upright in bed.

My heart is racing, but my head is clear.

Clearer than it's ever been.

The memory doesn't vanish.

It stays.

I press my fingers into the mattress, grounding myself.

He didn't show me this.

Elias didn't curate this.

That means something went wrong.

Or something inside me is healing faster than he can break it.

The door opens.

I don't jump.

That's another thing I've learned—startle responses make him suspicious.

Elias stands in the doorway, watching me like he's trying to decide whether I'm a threat or a patient.

"You're awake," he says.

"I had a nightmare," I reply softly.

True enough.

He walks in and sits beside me, his presence heavy and familiar. He doesn't touch me immediately. He studies my face first.

"What did you see?" he asks.

I hesitate.

Not because I'm afraid.

Because hesitation makes him lean in.

"A stairwell," I say. "But it didn't make sense."

He relaxes slightly.

Good.

"I couldn't see his face," I continue. "Just the feeling."

He nods. "Residual emotion."

"But I wasn't scared," I add.

His eyes flick to mine.

"I was… tired," I say carefully. "Like I'd already been afraid for too long."

That's when his expression changes.

Just a fraction.

That's not the reaction he expected.

"Tired how?" he asks.

I shrug. "Resigned, maybe."

He watches me closely now.

That's okay.

I'm ready.

"Does that mean you'll erase it?" I ask quietly.

"No," he says after a moment. "Not yet."

I swallow. "Because you said erasing too much too fast could damage me."

His lips curve faintly. "You remember that?"

"I remember things you repeat," I say.

That's true.

Repetition is his weakness.

He nods. "We'll monitor it."

He stands. "Try to sleep again."

I lie back obediently.

But my eyes stay open long after he leaves.

Because now I know something he doesn't.

The memories aren't coming back randomly.

They're coming back emotion first, image second.

Which means he can't predict them.

Which means he can't fully control them.

The next few days pass quietly.

Too quietly.

Elias loosens the leash just enough to test me. Short trips outside. Controlled social exposure. No unsupervised conversations.

I play my part.

I eat when he tells me to. I rest when he suggests it. I cry at appropriate moments and stay calm at others.

I let him believe he's stabilizing me.

But I start noticing things.

Like how his phone is always on silent—but never off.

How he never leaves me alone for more than forty minutes.

How Dr. Keene avoids eye contact now.

And then there's the new detail.

The one that changes everything.

We're sitting at the kitchen table one afternoon when Elias's phone lights up.

He flips it face-down immediately.

Too fast.

I've learned that reflex.

"Who was that?" I ask lightly.

"No one," he replies.

A lie.

A careless one.

"What if I asked to see your phone?" I say, testing.

He meets my gaze calmly. "You wouldn't like what you'd find."

"That's not an answer."

"It is," he says. "Just not a comforting one."

I nod, pretending to accept it.

Inside, something clicks into place.

Later that night, after he falls asleep, I move quietly through the apartment. Every step measured. Every breath controlled.

I stop beside the couch and look at the bookshelf again.

At the hidden panel.

At the burner phone.

I don't touch it.

Instead, I do something far more dangerous.

I check Elias's coat.

His wallet.

His keys.

And then—

His phone.

It's unlocked.

Of course it is.

He never thought I'd try.

I scroll carefully, heart pounding.

There's a new message thread.

The contact name is just a letter.

R.

I open it.

The last message is recent.

She's remembering without prompts.

My blood runs cold.

Another message beneath it.

If she reaches full recall, containment fails.

And then Elias's reply.

Then we move to Phase Two.

I stare at the screen, my hands trembling.

Phase Two.

I don't know what that means yet.

But I know one thing with absolute clarity.

This isn't about protecting me anymore.

It's about what happens

if I remember who I was

before he decided

who I was allowed to be.

I lock the phone and place it back exactly where I found it.

Then I sit on the edge of the bed and wait for morning.

Because I've made my decision.

I won't run blindly.

I won't confront him yet.

I won't ask for help from people who might already be compromised.

I'll stay.

I'll let him think I'm afraid.

I'll let him prepare Phase Two.

And when he finally decides to finish erasing me—

I'll make sure

I remember enough

to destroy him with the truth.

More Chapters