Elle's psychological evaluation was scheduled for 10 AM on a Tuesday.
I watched her prepare from across the bullpen—subtle tells that most people would miss. The slight movement of her lips as she rehearsed answers. The way her hands stayed deliberately relaxed, practicing the appearance of calm. The careful arrangement of her expression into something that looked like healthy processing.
[DECEPTION ANALYSIS: ACTIVE]
[SUBJECT PRACTICING COACHED RESPONSES]
[AUTHENTICITY INDICATORS: LOW]
[FOCUS: -3]
She was going to lie her way through the evaluation.
And she was going to succeed.
Dr. Kaufman's office was on the third floor—a comfortable space designed to put patients at ease, with soft lighting and neutral colors and the particular blandness of institutional therapy. I knew because I'd had my own evaluation there, back when I first joined the BAU.
The session lasted forty-five minutes.
I spent those forty-five minutes pretending to work while my mind cycled through scenarios. Elle would present the right answers—acknowledge the trauma, demonstrate coping strategies, express appropriate concern about returning too quickly. Kaufman would see a professional working through difficulty with admirable resilience.
Kaufman wouldn't see the rage that burned underneath.
Wouldn't see the darkness that had settled behind Elle's eyes since the shooting.
Wouldn't see the woman I loved disappearing behind walls of anger and performance.
[WARNING: PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT INCOMPLETE]
[SUBJECT DISPLAYED COACHED RESPONSES]
[TRUE STATE: MASKED]
Elle emerged at 10:47, paperwork in hand.
"Cleared," she announced. "Full field duty. Effective immediately."
The bullpen erupted in congratulations. Garcia appeared with a cake she'd somehow produced in under an hour. Morgan did an embarrassing victory dance that made even Hotch crack a smile. Reid quoted statistics about recovery rates that were meant to be reassuring.
Elle accepted it all with the appropriate responses—gratitude, humor, the performance of someone who'd conquered their demons.
I watched from my desk.
She fooled them. She fooled everyone.
Everyone except me.
The celebration wound down around noon. Elle accepted handshakes and well-wishes with the particular grace of someone who'd spent her whole career proving she belonged in rooms full of doubters.
When the attention finally shifted away, she caught my eye across the bullpen.
Her expression said: Don't.
I looked away.
The afternoon passed in the strange normalcy of a team that believed everything was fine. Cases were reviewed. Profiles were built. The machinery of the BAU continued turning while I sat at my desk and felt the weight of knowledge I couldn't share.
She's not ready. The evaluation was theater. She's going back into the field carrying wounds that haven't healed.
And there's nothing I can do without betraying her trust.
[DREAD METER: 19 → 21]
[INTERVENTION OPTIONS: LIMITED]
[CONSEQUENCE OF INACTION: UNKNOWN BUT CONCERNING]
That evening, Elle came to my apartment.
She didn't call first. Just appeared at my door around 9 PM, wearing civilian clothes and an expression I couldn't read.
"Can I come in?"
"Always."
She walked past me into the living room, looked around like she was seeing it for the first time.
"You cleaned," she observed.
"I've had time."
"Right. The whole 'staying behind while the team deploys' thing." She turned to face me. "That stops now. I'm cleared. We're partners again."
"I know."
"Do you?" She stepped closer. "Because you've been looking at me like I'm a problem to be solved. Like I'm broken."
"I don't think you're broken."
"Then what do you think?"
The question hung between us.
I think you lied to Kaufman. I think you're carrying rage you haven't processed. I think you're going to go back into the field and something is going to break.
But I can't say any of that without losing you.
"I think you're the strongest person I know," I said instead. "And I think you've been through something that would destroy most people. I'm worried because I care, not because I doubt you."
Elle studied my face, looking for lies.
"You're doing it again. Saying the right thing."
"Would you prefer I say the wrong thing?"
"I'd prefer you stop treating me like I'm fragile." She closed the distance between us. "I'm not fragile, Ethan. I'm not going to shatter. What I am is angry. And tired. And desperately in need of something that feels normal."
She kissed me before I could respond.
There was nothing gentle about it. Nothing soft. It was hunger and heat and the desperate need to feel something other than the darkness that had been consuming her for weeks.
I kissed her back.
This isn't healthy. This isn't healing.
But she's here. She's choosing this.
Maybe that's enough.
We didn't talk again until later, lying in the dark, the ceiling fan casting shadows that moved like waves.
"Don't tell me I'm not ready," Elle said quietly. "I know everyone thinks it. I need you to not be one of them."
"I won't."
"Promise?"
The word cost more than she knew.
"I promise."
She rolled toward me, her head on my chest, her breathing slowly evening toward sleep.
"First case is in three days," she murmured. "Something in Arizona. Hotch is putting me with you."
"I know. I requested it."
She looked up.
"Why?"
Because I can't protect you from the clearance, but maybe I can protect you in the field. Because watching from the bullpen was killing me. Because if something happens, I want to be there.
"Because we're partners," I said. "And partners watch each other's backs."
Elle was quiet for a long moment.
"Okay," she said finally. "Okay."
She settled back against my chest, and eventually her breathing steadied into sleep.
I stayed awake, staring at the ceiling, feeling the weight of everything I knew pressed against the warmth of her body against mine.
She lied to get cleared. She's going back into the field carrying wounds that no one else can see. And I promised not to tell her she's not ready.
What happens when those wounds tear open?
What happens when I can't protect her from herself?
[RELATIONSHIP STATUS: ELLE GREENAWAY]
[PHYSICALLY CLOSE — EMOTIONALLY DISTANT]
[TRUST: CONDITIONAL]
[TRAJECTORY: UNCERTAIN]
The system offered no answers.
Some things couldn't be calculated.
Some futures couldn't be predicted.
All I could do was be there—in the field, in her life, in whatever chaos was coming—and hope that being there would be enough.
Three days until Arizona.
Three days until Elle's first real test since the shooting.
Three days to figure out how to watch someone you love walk toward a cliff you can see but they can't.
I closed my eyes.
Sleep didn't come.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes .
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!