Bonus Chapter at 1200 PS
Support me at patreon.com/CulturedOne and read 50 Advanced Chapters
_______________________
A few days later, the date for the broadcast of the final episode of Puella Magi Madoka Magica finally arrived.
Rain had been falling incessantly over Tokyo since the early morning, and by nightfall, the drizzle showed no signs of letting up. Sumiko clutched her umbrella, sprinting through the wet streets toward her apartment.
Working late was bad enough, but the rain had delayed her commute even further. Fortunately, she checked her watch: 20:49. There were still eleven minutes left before the finale began.
She managed to scramble into a change of clothes just as her delivery order arrived. She spread her snacks across the table, dimmed the lights, and switched on the television.
The atmosphere in the room grew heavy and still.
At 9:00 PM sharp, The opening frames of the twelfth episode appeared on the screen.
The city where Madoka lived had been reduced to a wasteland of rubble by Walpurgisnacht.
Standing amidst the ruins in her human form, Madoka stepped in front of a completely exhausted Homura.
Her pink hair fluttered gently in the wind.
"I'm sorry, Homura-chan... I've decided to become a magical girl."
Madoka's gentle, smiling face was a dagger to Homura's heart, and it forced a deep, heavy sigh from Sumiko's chest. No matter how many times the world looped, Madoka would always choose to sacrifice herself for the sake of others. Homura had tried everything to stop her, but in the end, wasn't that selfless nature exactly what Homura loved about her?
"I've finally found the wish I want to realize," Madoka declared.
Sumiko wondered what kind of wish it could possibly be. Surely it was just a wish to defeat Walpurgisnacht, but that would only lead to Madoka falling into despair and becoming a world-ending witch herself. It was a perfect, cruel cycle. If Madoka didn't transform, the world was destroyed by Walpurgisnacht. If she did transform, the world was destroyed by her own hand.
"No! If you do that, then everything I've done... what was it all for?" Homura cried out, pleading with Madoka to stop.
A somber, melodic score began to play. Madoka knelt tenderly beside Homura, pulling her into a warm embrace.
"Thank you for protecting someone like me all this time. But please, believe in me. I won't let all your hard work go to waste."
Madoka's eyes hardened with resolve. She stood up and turned toward Kyubey.
"You said that since I've become the center of so much karma, I can realize any wish, no matter how grand, right?" Madoka asked. Kyubey appeared right on cue, its large, unblinking eyes fixed on her with an eerie charm.
"That is correct, Madoka. In exchange for your soul, what is your wish?"
Sumiko held her breath. Even though she suspected the plot would end with Madoka becoming a witch and Homura resetting the timeline yet again, seeing this version of Madoka pushed into a corner was still heartbreaking.
On the screen, Madoka took a deep breath. Then, she spoke the words that would be etched into the memories of millions of viewers across Japan.
"I want to erase all witches before they are even born. Every single witch, in every universe, in the past and the future... I want to destroy them with my own hands."
Kyubey's expression shifted as if it sensed something had gone terribly wrong, but once the ritual of the contract begins, it cannot be stopped. Sumiko sat stunned. The wish was complicated. It sounded almost too abstract to be real.
However, the anime spent the next several minutes meticulously illustrating exactly what that wish meant.
The writer had gone all out.
Two minutes later, Sumiko's eyes were wide with shock. It made her realize the true nature of Madoka's wish. Can someone actually wish for something like that?
According to the established rules of the show, the scale of a wish is determined by a girl's potential. If the potential isn't there, the wish fails.
But because of Homura's constant looping, Madoka had become the intersection for hundreds of parallel timelines.
Her karmic weight was vast enough to fuel a wish of universal proportions. Parallel universes, the past, the future, the present, she was going to hunt down every witch herself. This meant she was claiming the power to transcend time, space, and the very laws of the world. She was claiming the power to interfere with reality across all existence.
A being like that is what humans commonly refer to as a God. This was nothing like the fans had predicted. Everyone assumed the finale would be a group effort in a new loop to find a way to save everyone.
Instead, Madoka's body began to radiate a blinding, holy light.
"I don't want the magical girls who believed in hope to cry. I want them to be smiling until the very end. I will destroy any rule that stands in the way of that. I will change it all!"
"Now, come! Realize my wish!" Madoka was enveloped in a celestial glow.
Across Japan, countless fans were struck with awe. This show refused to stop surprising them. Even in the final episode, the writer, Warrior of Love, had delivered a twist.
Madoka had wished herself into godhood. She had bypassed the entire system of magical girls and witches.
But becoming a God came with a terrible price.
A god has no physical form, no friends, and no family. A god exists outside of causality, with no beginning and no end.
If Madoka was to become the savior who rescued magical girls from despair, her very existence would be erased from history. Aside from her consciousness becoming a fundamental law of the universe, every moment she spent with her friends and every memory her family had of her would vanish. Her footprint on the world would be reduced to zero.
This was the sacrifice the gentle Madoka made to create a world of love and justice where witches no longer existed. Once Sumiko understood this, she burst into tears. How could it end like this?
The fan forums were in a state of chaos.
"Wait, what is the Warrior of Love doing? Why couldn't he just let them reset the world normally? Why does Madoka have to do this?"
"I'm speechless. My brain has stopped working."
"Don't you get it? Everyone who was screaming for a reset so the girls could be revived was thinking too small. What point is there in Mami, Sayaka, and Kyoko looping through the same month forever?"
"They couldn't beat Walpurgisnacht, and even if they did, more powerful witches would eventually appear to crush them. The tragedy was the system itself, the fact that being a magical girl inevitably led to becoming a monster. Madoka's wish fixes the root of the problem. It ensures that when a girl dies, she doesn't become a monster that hurts the world she tried to protect. She makes the lives of magical girls actually mean something. It's the only true way to save them."
"But it's so lonely! To be a God that no one can even perceive... to fight for eternity in the past, present, and future and have no one know you ever existed... that's a fate worse than death. I would go insane."
"That's why it has to be Madoka. That's why she's the protagonist. The character depth she achieved in this one episode is staggering. Warrior of Love is a genius."
"I'm shaking. I can't believe this is happening. A show where the lead doesn't even transform until the final episode... I never would have believed it could be this powerful."
"All hail the birth of Goddess Madoka!"
This was the ultimate emotional peak of the series.
Every magical girl's fate played out in Sumiko's mind. Mami Tomoe dying just as she finally found companions; Sayaka Miki falling into despair as her ideals shattered; Kyoko Sakura sacrificing herself to stay with the friend she couldn't save; Homura Akemi failing a hundred times over a decade; and finally, Madoka Kaname giving up her humanity to save them all.
Each scene became a fresh wave of tears.
Madoka fired an arrow into the heavens.
The pink light pierced through the barriers of parallel worlds, transcending the limits of time and space. From the very first magical girl in ancient history to the distant future, Madoka was there at the moment of their death to take away their despair before they could turn into witches.
As Madoka transcended, history was rewritten.
Witches no longer existed, and Madoka was removed from the timeline. No one remembered her. However, because Homura was a user of time magic, she alone retained the memories of the girl she loved.
It was a happy ending for the world, but for Madoka, it was an eternal curse of solitude. She existed only as the Law of Cycles, an invisible force that tirelessly purged despair at the moment of death.
"I have no words. The imagination behind this ending is breathtaking."
"I can't believe a wish could be used that way."
"Madoka... she's too kind. It hurts to watch."
"Kyubey finally lost! Madoka's wish essentially bankrupted its entire model. It can never harvest energy from witches ever again."
"This episode is absolute perfection. I'm blown away."
"Madoka, Homura... my heart is breaking for them."
"I hate myself for crying this much over an anime."
"Warrior of Love isn't a monster. He really is a god of storytelling. How did he conceive of this?"
The praise was unanimous.
The viewership for Tokyo TV's Channel 1 had skyrocketed to 5.98%, hovering a hair's breadth away from the legendary 6% mark. The sight of Madoka in her beautiful, divine form left even the most cynical critics speechless.
Because history had changed, Mami was alive and well in the new world. Sayaka Miki's fate, however, was bittersweet; she had still used up her magic to save Kyosuke, but instead of becoming a monster, she was taken away peacefully by the Law of Cycles. Kyoko Sakura also remained alive, as she no longer had to die fighting a mermaid witch that never came to be.
In this restructured universe, Homura, Mami, and Kyoko were still fighting, but they were fighting Wraiths instead of witches.
The world was better, but the cost was the girl who started it all. Homura couldn't truly be happy; her wish was for Madoka's happiness, not for her to become an abstract concept. At the very end of the twelfth episode, a battle-worn Homura stood in a desolate landscape, fighting against new enemies with a look of exhaustion and simmering despair in her eyes.
In the final frames, black wings sprouted from her back, and the faint silhouette of a demon-like form appeared.
The screen faded to black.
Then, text appeared on the screen.
"The sequel to Puella Magi Madoka Magica, The Rebellion Story, is currently in production."
Sumiko couldn't take her eyes off the screen.
Even the most seasoned veterans couldn't have predicted this finale. After the initial shock wore off, a wave of emotion swept over the audience.
"Masterpiece! This is a total masterpiece!"
"This is the best work the industry has produced in a decade."
"The way he solved the impossible dilemma of the plot was genius."
"On paper, it's the ending with the least casualties, but it's the cruelest outcome for Homura. She did all of that just to see Madoka disappear."
"What did those final wings mean? Is Homura going to become a witch in the new world?"
"It has to be. She wanted Madoka to live a happy life, and Madoka is gone. Her despair is going to keep growing until it breaks the world again."
"And that teaser for The Rebellion Story! What is that?"
"A theatrical sequel... Warrior of Love knows exactly how to take our money."
"Does this mean it's coming straight to Blu-ray? I don't care, I'm buying it."
"I've been saving up for months, and now I know what for. I'm buying every single volume of this show."
"I need to find out who Warrior of Love actually is."
"I'm a wreck. What am I supposed to watch next week? Nothing can top this."
"Let's just celebrate the birth of a new legend in the industry."
"It's still the writer's fault! He could have given them a simple happy ending, but he chose this!"
"The ending was perfect and logical, but I'm still going to curse him for making me cry this much."
That night, the animation world was set ablaze. The final ratings for episode twelve were officially confirmed.