Chapter 59: Christmas Eve
The morning had the specific quality of December mornings when the city was winding down toward a holiday — less traffic noise, fewer voices on the street, a collective exhale before the pause. Andrew was up early, which Christie noted with suspicion when she emerged from her room at eight-thirty.
"Why are you dressed already?"
"We're going to see your mom."
The suspicion shifted into something more complicated. She stood in the kitchen doorway in her socks and said nothing for a moment.
"I was going to go tomorrow," she said. "Christmas Day."
"I know. I moved it."
"You moved my visit."
"You can move it back if you want." He poured her a glass of orange juice and set it on the counter. "But you should go either way."
She looked at the juice. Looked at him. The particular Christie calculus ran behind her eyes — the part that wanted to refuse on principle versus the part that had already made peace with the fact that he was usually right about the things that mattered and wrong about almost everything else.
"Fine," she said.
Rikers Island in December was its own specific atmosphere — the bridge over the East River, the low gray sky, the institutional quality of a place designed to be navigated rather than experienced. Andrew had filled out the visitation paperwork two weeks prior. Christie had her ID. The process was what it was: forms, waiting, the walk through the checkpoint, the waiting room with its plastic chairs and fluorescent hum.
Bonnie came to the glass looking better than Andrew had expected. She'd put on a little weight — the particular filling-out that happened when someone who'd been running on adrenaline and bad decisions finally stopped moving. There were two small bandages on her cheekbone, which neither of them commented on. She was navigating whatever hierarchy existed in her housing unit, apparently.
"Christie." Bonnie's hand came up slightly, a reflex, stopping before it reached the glass.
Christie sat down. Her face was composed in the way it was composed when she was managing something. "Hey."
"You look good," Bonnie said. Then, as though surprised by her own observation: "You look really good."
"I'm okay." Christie's voice was neutral. Not cold — neutral. The difference mattered. "Are you okay?"
"I'm—" Bonnie glanced at Andrew briefly, then back. "I'm fine. My cellmate's not bad. The food is—" She stopped. Started again. "I'm fine."
Andrew stood slightly back, giving them the space the glass allowed, which wasn't much.
He watched Christie's profile and found himself somewhere else without intending to.
He'd been thirteen. His dad — Evan, who was charming and unreliable in the specific proportion that made the unreliability harder to account for — had called him from the 19th Precinct on a Saturday afternoon. Drunk and disorderly. He'd taken a swing at the hood of a parked car with a bottle, and when the responding officer had put a hand on his shoulder, Evan had expressed his feelings about that physically.
Andrew had taken the subway uptown with Evan's wallet and ID in a paper bag, because that was what had been asked of him.
They'd sat across from each other at a table in the waiting area. Evan had been sober by then, in the specific deflated way that came after a night in holding, and he'd looked at Andrew with the expression of a man who knew exactly what he'd done and had already begun constructing the framework that would allow him to do it again. After a long silence, what he'd said was: How've you been? You doing okay at school?
Andrew had said: Fine. Everything's fine.
It hadn't been fine. He'd been having a bad semester in the specific invisible way that happened when nobody was paying close enough attention — his grades sliding, the social architecture of his school rearranged in ways that left him on the wrong side of it, and a girl he'd been too afraid to say anything to for two years who he'd find out much later had been waiting for him to say something.
He'd said fine. Evan had nodded with relief and moved on.
He thought about that now, watching Christie tell her mother she was okay, watching Bonnie receive it with the same relieved gratitude.
The thing he'd understood recently — not all at once, more like something that had been assembling itself from pieces over months — was that he'd spent a long time deciding the world owed him a debt it hadn't paid. Evan's failures. The school. The girl. The accumulated arithmetic of a childhood that hadn't been fair. He'd carried that ledger carefully, added to it regularly, found in it an explanation for everything that hadn't worked out.
What he'd been slower to see was the thing underneath it: the specific cruelty of hoping that others would fail. Not consciously. Not something he'd have admitted. But it was there — the part of him that had watched Christie moving toward something better and felt, underneath the genuine care, a flicker of something uglier. If I couldn't do it, why should it be easier for her?
He'd turned that over for a while and hadn't liked what he found.
The thing about ugly truths was that seeing them clearly was the first requirement. You couldn't address something you were still looking away from.
Everything is my fault was too simple. It wasn't all his fault. Evan had genuinely failed him. The circumstances had genuinely been hard. But he'd also had choices at every point — small ones, available ones — and he'd sometimes chosen the version that confirmed the story he was already telling himself.
He was twenty-one years old in this life. He had time to choose differently.
Christie was asking her mother about the daily routine, the practical questions, her voice still neutral but with something underneath it that was choosing to show up. Bonnie was answering with the flustered gratitude of someone who hadn't expected to be asked.
Andrew looked at the fluorescent light and felt something that had been taking up space for a long time quietly vacate it.
Visiting hours ended at noon. They walked to the bus stop without talking, which was the right amount of talking.
On the bridge back, Christie put her hands in her pockets and looked at the water.
"She seemed okay," she said finally.
"She did."
"The bandages—"
"She's figuring out how to be in there," Andrew said. "That takes a while."
Christie nodded slowly. Accepting this as the adult fact it was.
"I don't need it to be different than it is," she said. It was carefully worded — the sentence of someone who had thought about what she actually meant before saying it.
"I know," Andrew said.
She looked at him. "Did you go through something like this? With your dad?"
He thought about the precinct waiting room. The paper bag with the wallet. How've you been?
"Yeah," he said. "Something like it."
She seemed to file this away. She didn't ask for more, which was the thing about Christie — she understood instinctively that information offered itself when it was ready and pushing didn't help.
They found a diner on the way back to the subway and ate lunch without ceremony — grilled cheese for her, a club sandwich for him, coffee that was mediocre and exactly what the moment called for.
[Cooking (Proficient): 84/100]
Unchanged. Someone else's mediocre coffee didn't instruct him. He noted this with mild amusement.
Back in Manhattan by two. Christie went to her room with her practice exam materials and closed the door with the purposeful click of someone who had processed enough for one day and was ready to work.
Andrew stood in the kitchen and started thinking about dinner.
Jade was finishing her last shift of the year at four — the studio was closing through New Year's, which she'd mentioned with the equanimity of someone who had already calculated the financial implications and decided not to let them ruin her holiday. She'd be free by five-thirty.
He had a plan.
Drop the groceries, set up the table properly, go meet her from work, walk her back through the snow, let her see the apartment with candles and something cooking and the specific atmosphere of someone who had put in the effort because the occasion warranted it.
He wrote a list and went to the store.
The greenmarket on Columbus still had good produce — he found shallots and fresh thyme, a piece of beef tenderloin that was exactly right, good butter, a bottle of Burgundy that the man behind the counter confirmed was drinking well now rather than needing another three years. He bought a second bottle because it was Christmas Eve and that was a defensible decision.
[Cooking (Proficient): 84/100]
He was going to move that number tonight.
Back in the apartment, Christie emerged from her room at some point, stood in the kitchen doorway watching him work, and said nothing for a long moment.
"You're in a weird mood," she said.
"Good weird or bad weird?"
She considered. "Just weird. Like you figured something out."
"Maybe."
She looked at the tenderloin. "Is that for tonight?"
"It is."
"Am I eating here?"
"Monica's," he said. "I called her this afternoon. She said yes."
Christie processed this. The offer to spend Christmas Eve with Monica Geller, who had fed her twice and treated her like a person worth feeding properly, versus an evening alone in the apartment.
"Fine," she said, in the tone that meant she was pleased and wasn't going to perform otherwise.
He seasoned the tenderloin and put it in to rest.
[Cooking (Proficient): 85/100]
There it was.
He set the table with the actual tablecloth — the one he'd bought at the linen store on 72nd and never used because it had seemed like something you saved for an occasion. He put candles in the holders he'd found at the back of a kitchen cabinet, lit them once to check the height, then blew them out to relight later. He opened one of the Burgundies to breathe.
He stood back and looked at the apartment.
He'd been finding reasons for months. Good reasons, some of them — the timing wasn't right, they were still new, the words deserved the right moment. True things, all of them. Also, underneath them, something less true: the part that had decided, back in the other life, that people like him didn't get to say those words and mean them without something going wrong.
He was done listening to that part.
Tonight was the night. He'd known it since the visiting room, watching Christie choose to show up for her mother anyway, watching Bonnie's hand rise and stop at the glass, and feeling something in himself stop resisting.
He checked his reflection in the dark window above the sink.
Then he put on his coat and went to meet her.
[500 PS unlocks 1 Extra Chapter]
[10 Reviews unlock 1 Extra Chapter]
Thanks for reading—reviews are appreciated.
P1treon Soulforger has 20+advance chapters