Chapter 6: The One with the Blackout Story (Continued)
The candles on the coffee table had burned down about a third of the way. Outside, the city was still dark — that strange, rare New York dark that made the whole place feel like it was holding its breath. Inside Monica's apartment, everyone had migrated into their usual positions: Monica and Rachel on the couch,
Ross in the armchair, Joey sprawled on the floor with his back against the couch, Phoebe cross-legged beside the menorah. Ethan had the other armchair and the complete attention of the room.
He'd started the story ten minutes ago. Philadelphia, 1776, a traitor in the Continental Army. The atmosphere was perfect. The candlelight was doing exactly what candlelight was supposed to do.
Then he introduced the villain.
Ethan leaned forward, dropping his voice to the particular register of a man who had fully committed to a storytelling mode and intended to stay there.
"The most dangerous man in Philadelphia went by a name that nobody said above a whisper," he began. "They called him Mr. Bing. Chandler Bing. His eyes were the color of a problem you couldn't solve, and his loyalties had been for sale so long that he'd forgotten what they'd originally cost. He operated out of a building near the waterfront that everyone in the city knew about and nobody talked about — because the people who talked about it had a habit of not being around to talk about anything else shortly afterward."
"I can hear this, you know," came Chandler's voice through the phone, which Monica was holding up toward the group like a relay antenna. "The vestibule has excellent acoustics. Jill and I are both listening."
"Hi, Jill," Joey said toward the phone.
A pause from the other end.
"She waved," Chandler reported.
"He's been in there two hours and she's already waving at his friends," Rachel said. "That man lives a completely different life than the rest of us."
"Continue," Monica said to Ethan, lowering the phone slightly.
Ethan continued.
"Mr. Bing had called a meeting. On one side of the table sat the most powerful smuggling operation on the Eastern Seaboard, run by a man named Michael Corleone—"
"Isn't that from The Godfather?" Ross said.
"It's an homage."
"It's a direct lift."
"Ross, it's 1776. The Godfather hasn't been made yet. In this universe, Michael Corleone is a real person with a real smuggling operation and a very intimidating dining room. Moving on." Ethan picked up the thread without breaking pace. "Mr. Bing looked across the table at old Michael and said, very quietly, that he wanted the package handled. Permanently."
"What does that mean?" Joey asked. "Handled how?"
"Permanently how?" Rachel added.
"It means exactly what it sounds like," Ethan said. "Mr. Bing was not a man who required a lot of clarification."
"He sounds terrifying," Phoebe said approvingly. "I like him. As a villain."
"Chandler," Monica said toward the phone. "Your character is terrifying."
"Tell him he's also well-dressed," Chandler said. "I feel like he's well-dressed."
"He's impeccably dressed," Ethan confirmed. "Villain budget. Very good tailor."
"Okay," Chandler said, somewhat mollified. "Continue."
Ethan picked up the narrative thread and pulled.
On the other side of the city from Mr. Bing's operation, he explained, there was a student theater company that had accidentally become the most effective intelligence-gathering unit in the Continental Army. Nobody had planned it that way. It had simply turned out that actors were very good at being people they weren't — which made them extraordinarily useful in a war that ran largely on deception.
The company had just finished a performance. Packed house, standing ovation, the kind of night that made you feel, briefly, like everything was going to be fine. They were backstage, still in costume, when Joey climbed up on a prop box and told them what his contact in the Intelligence Command had passed along.
"Joey was the kind of man," Ethan narrated, "who walked into a room and immediately became the most important person in it — not because he demanded it, but because he simply couldn't help it."
Joey sat up straighter on the floor. "That's accurate."
"He had the bearing of someone who expected things to go well," Ethan continued, "which meant they usually did. He looked around the assembled company and said: There's a meeting tomorrow night. Chandler Bing and Michael Corleone, sitting in the same room. If we're ever going to move, it has to be now."
Joey nodded along with his own fictional self approvingly.
"At which point," Ethan said, "the three supporting members of the company immediately began discussing their personal plans for the holiday weekend."
"Excuse me?" Monica said.
"Historically accurate," Ethan said pleasantly.
"I was not—"
"Monica. You were distracted by a catering opportunity. It's fine. Joey handles it."
Joey squared his shoulders with the dignity of a man given important narrative responsibilities. Ethan continued:
"Joey stood up straighter. He said — and I want everyone to appreciate the delivery here, because it was exceptional — he said: Stop. We are talking about a traitor who has sent men to their deaths and sold out his own country for money. Our plays have made people cry. Our performances have made people feel things they forgot they could feel. But none of that matters as much as what we could do tomorrow night."
A pause.
Rachel had her chin in her hand. "That's actually a really good speech."
"Thank you," Joey said, as if he had personally written it.
"Monica asked," Ethan continued, "'Are you suggesting we moonlight as assassins?'"
"That seems like a reasonable question," Monica said.
"Joey said: I'm suggesting we be exactly what we've always been. People who play a role so convincingly that nobody questions whether it's real."
Phoebe pressed both hands to her heart. "That's beautiful."
"It really is," Ethan agreed. "Joey has good lines in this story."
"I contain multitudes," Joey said.
"Okay," Monica said, leaning forward. "My turn."
Ethan looked at her. "Monica, I'm in the middle of—"
"You've been the protagonist for twenty solid minutes," Monica said. "You said everyone gets to be in this story. I'd like to be in the story."
"You're already in the story. You're running the operation."
"I'd like to narrate the story. Briefly. The next part."
A pause. Ethan looked around the room. Nobody came to his defense, which was, he felt, a betrayal.
"Fine," he said. "Go ahead."
Monica took the narration with the comfortable authority of someone who had been waiting for exactly this.
She described how Ethan and Joey had fought valiantly — she was generous on this point, giving Ethan credit for at least three separate impressive moments before the tide turned — but had ultimately been overwhelmed by the sheer number of guards. And then, Monica noted with entirely too much pleasure, an explosive device near the eastern wall had briefly but definitively taken Ethan out of commission.
Ethan stared at her. "I'm sorry, I was what?"
"Caught in a blast," Monica said. "You survived. Mostly."
"I'm the narrator. The narrator cannot be incapacitated. That violates the fundamental—"
"The narrator," Monica said, with the serenity of a woman who had thought this through, "can be briefly sidelined, which creates narrative space for other characters to step up. It's a classic device."
"Did you just cite narrative theory at me?"
"You've been talking for twenty minutes, Ethan. I've been paying attention."
Ethan opened his mouth. Closed it. "Continue," he said, with the dignity of a man accepting a temporary defeat.
Monica's version of events pivoted around a new character: a celebrated performer who happened to be in Philadelphia for a series of benefit concerts and who, through circumstances Monica described with impressive efficiency, ended up in exactly the right position to finish what Ethan and Joey had started.
This performer went by one name.
Monica paused. She looked at the room. She said, with significant pageantry: "Courteney."
A beat.
Ross said: "Like—"
"Yes," Monica said.
Rachel said: "Isn't that—"
"It's an homage," Monica said.
"You literally used my word," Ethan said.
"Courteney," Monica continued, unbothered, "was the most celebrated performer on the Eastern Seaboard. When she walked into a room, everything else stopped. Mr. Bing, for all his cruelty and calculation, was not immune. Nobody was."
She paused for effect.
"She received rather a lot of flowers from Mr. Bing — and a fairly aggressive amount of cash — and she accepted the invitation to meet with him, because she understood that sometimes the most important thing a woman can do is walk directly toward the thing everyone else is walking away from."
"Okay," Ethan said, despite himself. "That's well-written."
"Thank you," Monica said.
"You're still blowing me up to set up your own entrance."
"The story needed momentum."
"I am the momentum—"
"What did she bring to the meeting?" Joey interrupted, completely invested now and no longer interested in the structural argument.
Monica paused for effect.
"Her good judgment," she said. "A change of clothes." Another pause. "And an ice pick."
Joey pointed at the ceiling. "She means business."
"I am very into this story," Ross said. "And I still haven't appeared."
"Neither have I," Rachel said.
"You two are in the next—" Ethan started.
And then every light in the apartment came on at once.
The television flickered to life mid-commercial. The refrigerator hummed back into existence. The microwave clock blinked 12:00 with the cheerful persistence of a machine that had no memory of the last two hours and no interest in acquiring one.
For a moment, nobody moved. They all sat there blinking in the sudden light like people emerging from a very good movie that had ended too soon.
Joey said: "No. No. We were at the ice pick."
"Monica had just gotten to Mr. Bing's house," Phoebe said.
"Ross and I haven't even been in the story yet," Rachel said.
"You specifically said the next part," Ross said. "Those were your exact words. The next part."
Ethan stood up, stretched, and assumed the serene expression of a man who had just been rescued from having to figure out how the ice pick scene was going to resolve.
"The story will continue," he said. "Another time. When the conditions are right."
"The conditions were perfect," Joey said. "It was dark. We had candles. There was a menorah."
"The city has made other plans for tonight."
"You owe us a continuation," Monica said. "That's a formal debt."
"Noted," Ethan said. "Also — five dollars."
Monica gave him a look that communicated a great many things at once. Then she reached for her purse.
They were still arguing about the story — Joey lobbying for more scenes, Ross pointing out that the spy character hadn't done anything yet, Rachel making a strong case that Hathaway deserved a more prominent role in act two — when the door opened and Chandler walked in.
He had the particular expression of a man who had experienced something genuinely remarkable and was still in the process of deciding what to do with it. His hair was slightly disheveled. He looked, overall, like someone who had spent two hours in a glass vestibule with Jill Goodacre, which was because he had.
He stood in the doorway and looked around at all of them — the melted candles, the menorah on the coffee table, the five-dollar bill sitting on the table, everyone's faces — and said:
"What did I miss?"
"We told a story," Joey said. "You were the villain."
Chandler processed this. "I was the what."
"Mr. Bing," Ethan said. "Notorious traitor. Impeccable wardrobe. Very menacing presence. We gave you good material."
Chandler stared at him. "You made the villain Chandler Bing."
"It felt right," Ethan said. "The name has a certain energy."
"The name is my name, Ethan."
"Which is exactly why it has energy."
Chandler stood in the doorway for another moment, working through this. "Did I at least get a good ending?"
"The power came back before we got there."
"So I'm an unresolved villain."
"With hidden depths," Ethan said. "And I should mention — before the power came back, I issued a prophecy. Mr. Bing finds true love. Very dramatic. The candles were at exactly the right height for it."
Chandler looked at him for a long moment. "In the story."
"In the story," Ethan said. "And potentially as a broader statement about your general trajectory."
Chandler looked around the apartment — the warm light now, the friends, the lived-in furniture, the coffee table with its candle wax rings and Phoebe's guitar pick and the five-dollar bill Monica had just surrendered.
"True love," he said. "Here."
"I stand by the prophecy," Ethan said. "I also predicted the blackout."
"And you were right about that."
"Two for two."
Chandler sat down, pulled the blanket from the back of the couch across his lap, and settled in the way people do when they've decided they're not going home yet.
"Next time there's a story," he said, "I want a better role."
"Next time," Ethan said, "get here before the power comes back."
Before he left, Ethan caught Ross alone in the kitchen for thirty seconds while Monica organized a rematch — cards tomorrow, boys versus girls, twenty dollars, no disputing the rules after the fact.
"She was laughing tonight," Ethan said quietly. "Rachel. Real laughing, not the kind people do when they're keeping it together."
Ross looked at his coffee cup.
"I'm just noting it," Ethan said. "For the record."
Ross nodded slowly. Not a commitment. But not nothing either.
That was enough for tonight.
Ethan walked Phoebe home through a city that had gotten its lights back, the streets wet and gleaming from an earlier drizzle, the neon doing its usual work, New York being itself again after its brief strange interruption.
Phoebe had her guitar slung over one shoulder and her coat buttoned to the top, and she walked with the unhurried pace of someone who was always exactly where she meant to be.
"Can I ask you something?" she said.
"Sure."
"The narrator character. The mysterious traveler from the future." She glanced at him sideways. "How much of that was the story?"
Ethan walked a few steps without answering.
"Do you ever feel like you already know how things go?" she said. "Not just tonight. Like, in general. Like you've seen the shape of it before."
He looked up at the buildings — the lit windows, all those separate lives running parallel in the dark, all those stories he couldn't fully know even when he thought he could.
"Sometimes," he said.
"And?"
"And I think even if you know the general shape of things — the broad outline, the rough direction — the specific version of it, this version, with these people, right now?" He paused. "You can't know that in advance. That part you actually have to be here for."
Phoebe was quiet for a moment, turning this over.
"That's a good answer," she said finally.
"I've been working on it," he said.
She laughed — easy and genuine — and hummed something quietly to herself as they walked, not quite a song yet, just a melody still looking for the right words.
The city settled around them, lit and breathing again, the night doing what New York nights do best: holding everything at once and making it feel, somehow, like enough.
Next time on the story: Ross appears. Rachel gets a scene. Chandler Bing gets a better role. Monica disputes all of the above.
The cappuccino remains uncollected.
[Reader Event Active]
500 Power Stones = +1 Extra Chapter
10 Reviews = +1 Extra Chapter
Thanks for reading!
20+advance chapters on P1treon Soulforger