Chapter 3: Prove It or Lose It
The crime scene was a house in a quiet neighborhood that screamed upper-middle-class stability. White picket fence. Trimmed lawn. A basketball hoop over the garage with a net that had seen better days. Everything about it said this family did everything right, which made the yellow crime scene tape feel like a violation of cosmic justice.
Chief Vick had driven me herself. Detective Lassiter followed in a separate car, radiating hostility like a space heater set to maximum. He hadn't said a word to me since Vick had announced I'd be "consulting" on the Ramos kidnapping.
I could feel his skepticism from twenty feet away. The system probably had a metric for it.
[LASSITER HOSTILITY LEVEL: 94%. NEW PERSONAL BEST. CONGRATULATIONS?]
The victim's name was Maria Ramos. Twenty-three years old. Grad student at UC Santa Barbara. She'd disappeared from her family home while house-sitting for her parents, who'd been visiting relatives in Phoenix. No signs of forced entry. No ransom note. The only clue was a window left open in the back bedroom — a detail the police had written off as Maria forgetting to close it before bed.
I knew better. I knew everything better, because I'd watched this episode at least six times.
The kidnapper was Maria's ex-boyfriend. Controlling, possessive, unable to accept that she'd ended the relationship. He'd used the key she'd never asked him to return. He'd taken her to his family's old boathouse — abandoned after his father's death, never sold because of sentimental attachment and also because it was perfect for hiding someone you weren't legally allowed to be within five hundred feet of.
I knew all of this.
The system knew that I knew.
[META-KNOWLEDGE DETECTED. WARNING: XP REWARDS WILL BE REDUCED IF DEDUCTIONS ARE NOT EARNED THROUGH OBSERVATION. THE SYSTEM REWARDS SKILL, NOT MEMORY.]
I'd worry about that later. Right now, a woman's life depended on me performing well enough to keep Vick's conditional trust.
"The bedroom." I walked through the front door without waiting for permission. "That's where it started."
Lassiter followed close behind. "How do you know that? You just got here."
"The spirits are guiding me." I kept my voice light, mystical, annoying. "Also, common sense. Kidnappings that don't show forced entry usually start in private spaces. Bedrooms, bathrooms, anywhere the victim feels safe enough to let their guard down."
"That's not psychic. That's basic procedure."
"And yet you asked how I knew."
I found the bedroom. Pink walls — Maria had grown up here, never redecorated after college. Posters of bands I vaguely recognized. A desk with textbooks and a laptop the police had already seized for analysis.
The window was closed now, but the latch told me everything I needed.
[SHAWN VISION ACTIVATING]
Three highlights. The window latch, glowing gold. A framed photograph on the desk. And a small mark on the carpet near the closet door that wanted to be significant but probably wasn't.
I focused on the latch first. Scratches. Fresh ones, barely visible without close examination. Someone had worked this latch from the outside, but done it carefully — not breaking in, just... unlocking.
"He had a key," I said, touching my temple for the performance. "I'm sensing... a relationship. Someone close. Someone who had access."
Vick's expression sharpened. "The boyfriend."
"Ex-boyfriend." I moved to the photograph. Maria with her arm around a young man, both of them smiling in front of what looked like a marina. The frame was dusty everywhere except for one corner — where someone had picked it up recently and set it back down. "She ended it, but he couldn't accept that. The window wasn't left open by accident. He opened it from the inside after he came through the front door. He wanted it to look like a break-in, but he was too careful. No forced entry because he still had her key."
"We already considered the ex-boyfriend," Lassiter cut in. "He has an alibi. Was at his cousin's house all night."
"His cousin is lying."
"Based on what? Your 'spirits'?"
I turned to face him. The system pinged a warning about Lassiter's hostility spiking again, but I ignored it. This was the moment. This was where the performance either sold the lie or collapsed under its own absurdity.
"Based on the photograph." I pointed at the marina background. "Water. Wood. Something old, something abandoned. The spirits are showing me a place that hasn't been used in years, but he remembers it. His family's place. Near the water." I closed my eyes, reached deeper into the memory of the episode, translated it into mystical nonsense. "A boathouse. Belonging to someone who died. The father... no, grandfather? Someone he lost. He goes there when he needs to feel in control."
Vick's phone was already in her hand. "I need someone to pull property records on Daniel Whitmore. Anything connected to his family. Waterfront properties, specifically boathouses or marinas."
"Chief, you can't seriously—" Lassiter started.
"I can and I am." Vick's voice cut like a blade. "We've had thirty-six hours of nothing, Carlton. If this leads nowhere, I'll personally apologize to your skepticism. But right now, I'm following the lead."
The property records came back in twenty minutes. A boathouse near the Santa Barbara harbor, owned by the Whitmore family trust, listed as unoccupied since 1998.
We took three cars. Vick in front. Lassiter driving like he wanted to hit something. Me in the back of Vick's sedan, watching the harbor approach through the window and trying to keep my breakfast down.
This was real. A real kidnapping victim. A real dangerous ex-boyfriend. And if I was wrong — if my memory of a television episode didn't perfectly match this version of reality — Maria Ramos would stay missing while I went to jail for obstruction of justice and probably accessory charges they'd make up just to punish me for wasting their time.
[SYSTEM NOTE: THE HOST'S ELEVATED HEART RATE HAS BEEN LOGGED. CONSIDER BREATHING. IT'S USUALLY HELPFUL.]
The boathouse was exactly where I remembered it. Grey wood, weathered by decades of salt air. A dock that listed slightly to one side. Windows covered with plastic sheeting that had yellowed with age.
And a car parked behind the structure. A car that matched Daniel Whitmore's registration.
"Weapons out," Vick ordered quietly. "Lassiter, you take the back. I'll take the front. Spencer—"
"I'll stay here and try not to die."
"Good choice."
They moved. I stayed by the cars, heart hammering, watching trained professionals do the job I'd essentially handed them the solution to. The system displayed a timer I hadn't asked for — seconds ticking by like they mattered, which they did, because Maria Ramos had been trapped in that boathouse for almost two days.
Shouting. A crash. More shouting.
Then Vick's voice, clear and controlled: "Maria Ramos! You're safe! We've got you!"
I let out a breath I hadn't realized I'd been holding.
[CASE: RAMOS KIDNAPPING — STATUS: RESOLVED][VICTIM: RECOVERED ALIVE][PERPETRATOR: APPREHENDED][XP EARNED: 45]
The number was lower than I'd expected. The system helpfully explained why.
[XP REDUCTION APPLIED: META-KNOWLEDGE SHORTCUT DETECTED. HOST UTILIZED PRE-EXISTING KNOWLEDGE OF CASE OUTCOME RATHER THAN DEDUCTIVE OBSERVATION. STANDARD REWARD: ~85 XP. ADJUSTED REWARD: 45 XP.]
[SYSTEM PHILOSOPHY REMINDER: THE PDCS REWARDS SKILL ACQUISITION, NOT TRIVIA RECALL. FUTURE CASES SHOULD EMPHASIZE LEGITIMATE DEDUCTION OVER MEMORY EXPLOITATION.]
[TRANSLATED: EARN YOUR ANSWERS NEXT TIME, CHEATER.]
I stared at the notification. The system could tell. It could actually tell when I was using foreknowledge versus real observation. Which meant the advantage I'd assumed would carry me through the early seasons — my complete memory of every case, every culprit, every twist — was worth roughly half the experience points.
The safety net had a cost.
The sun was setting by the time we got back to the station. Maria Ramos had been taken to the hospital — dehydrated, traumatized, but alive. Daniel Whitmore was in booking, facing kidnapping charges that would put him away for at least a decade. Lassiter hadn't spoken to me since the arrest, which I counted as a minor victory.
Chief Vick called me into her office.
"Mr. Spencer." She gestured to a chair. I sat. "I don't know what you are. Psychic, lucky, or something else entirely. Frankly, I don't care. You found Maria Ramos when my entire department couldn't. That matters."
"Thank you, Chief."
"I'm not finished." She leaned back in her chair. "I'm prepared to offer you a consulting position with the SBPD. Unofficial, off the books, plausibly deniable if you embarrass me. You'll be paid per case, and you'll work under the direct supervision of whichever detective I assign. Probably Lassiter."
"He loves me."
"He thinks you're a con artist."
"So that's a 'no' on the love, then."
Vick almost smiled. Almost.
"Do we have a deal?"
I thought about it. About the system and its reduced XP and its warnings about earning my deductions. About Shawn Spencer's life stretching out ahead of me — eight seasons of cases, relationships, personal growth that I now had to actually live instead of watch from the comfort of my couch.
About Gus, who I hadn't even met yet. About Juliet O'Hara, who would transfer to the SBPD in a few months. About Henry Spencer, who I'd have to face as the son he'd raised and then lost to — whatever I was. A replacement. A pretender. A ghost wearing his boy's face.
The scope of it hit me all at once. This wasn't a game. The system made it feel like one, with its XP and achievements and sarcastic commentary, but beneath all that interface design was a real life. Real people. Real consequences.
And I was committed now.
"Deal." I shook Vick's hand. "When do I start?"
"You already did." She handed me a temporary badge. "Welcome to the SBPD, Mr. Spencer. Try not to make me regret this."
The harbor was quiet as I walked along the dock where we'd found Maria Ramos. The boathouse was sealed with crime scene tape, but I didn't need to go inside. I just needed to stand somewhere and process what had happened today.
I sat on the edge of the dock. My feet hung over the water. The sunset turned everything gold and pink, postcard-perfect California colors that Dennis Chapman from Chicago would never have believed were real.
[STATUS UPDATE][HOST LEVEL: 1 (45/100 XP TO LEVEL 2)][PSYCHIC CREDIBILITY RATING: 12%][CASES SOLVED: 1][CONSULTANT STATUS: ACHIEVED]
The system paused. Then, in a different font — softer somehow, less sarcastic:
[GOOD JOB TODAY.]
Another pause.
[NOW DO IT AGAIN WITHOUT THE CHEAT CODES.]
I laughed. Couldn't help it. The sound echoed across the water and startled a pelican into flight.
Tomorrow I needed to find Gus. Convince him to partner up. Open Psych. Start building the life that Shawn Spencer was supposed to have, except now it would be me living it. Me making the choices. Me figuring out how to be a person who faked psychic powers for a living while a sarcastic video game system judged his every deduction.
But that was tomorrow.
Tonight, I watched the sunset and ate nothing because I'd forgotten to bring food, and my stomach growled loud enough to scare another pelican.
[BIOLOGICAL NEED DETECTED: HUNGER. RECOMMENDATION: EAT SOMETHING. PINEAPPLE IS TRADITIONAL.]
Gus's pharmaceutical sales route passed through downtown Santa Barbara at 11 AM. I remembered that detail from three rewatches of the pilot — the scene where Shawn ambushes his best friend at a client meeting.
Tomorrow at eleven, I'd be there.
Tonight, I walked back to Shawn's apartment and ordered the largest pizza the
Get Early Access to New Chapters
Thank you for reading. For those who want to skip the wait, my Patreon is currently 21 chapters ahead of the public sites.
Schedule: 7 new chapters released every 10 days.
Benefit: Gain a significant lead of 7 to 21 chapters depending on your tier.
Support the project and start reading the next arc now: Patreon.com/IsekaiStories