Chapter 18: The Weight of Death
Mac hadn't slept in thirty-six hours. Every time he closed his eyes, he saw Ethan's face in that final moment—surprise giving way to understanding as the stake found his heart. The image burned behind his eyelids like a brand, impossible to escape or forget.
His hands—the same hands that had healed Charlie's crushed throat just hours before—had built the trap that killed a man. Had held the weapon. Had driven it home with precision that spoke of intention rather than accident.
Mac sat in Fort Probably-Won't-Collapse, staring at his palms as if they belonged to someone else. They looked normal—no blood visible, no outward sign of what they'd done. But he could feel the weight of Ethan's life on them like invisible stains that would never wash clean.
The cognitive dissonance tore at him. These were hands that had saved Gary Morrison's life on the beach, that had healed Boone's internal bleeding, that had eased Claire's pain and built shelter for dozens of survivors. But they were also hands that had killed with calculated efficiency.
He tried to build something—anything—to quiet the screaming in his head, but his fingers wouldn't cooperate. For the first time since discovering his Master Builder abilities, the power simply refused to respond. He'd broken something inside himself, crossed a line that had severed his connection to the constructive aspects of his nature.
"Mac?" Charlie's voice carried from outside the shelter, hesitant but determined.
"Come in," Mac said without looking up.
Charlie appeared at the entrance, moving carefully but showing no signs of his recent near-death experience. Mac's healing had been thorough—Charlie was physically fine, but his eyes held new understanding of how close he'd come to dying.
"You saved my life," Charlie said. "Again. And you protected Claire. That's all that matters."
Mac couldn't meet his eyes. "I killed him, Charlie. Deliberately. With intent. What does that make me?"
Charlie was quiet for a long moment, processing the weight of Mac's confession.
"Alive," Charlie said finally. "And so am I, because of you."
POV: Kate
Kate watched the camp's dynamics shift around Mac's actions like water finding new channels after an earthquake. The divisions that had formed around his impossible abilities were now fracturing further along moral lines that cut deeper than simple trust or suspicion.
Claire called Mac a hero, her gratitude transcending words. She'd taken to visiting his shelter hourly, bringing food he wouldn't eat and comfort he couldn't accept. Her protection of him was fierce and absolute—anyone who criticized Mac's actions faced her maternal fury.
Hurley worried about Mac but remained supportive, his simple moral framework easily accommodating necessary violence in defense of innocents. "Dude saved Charlie and Claire," Hurley said to anyone who'd listen. "That Other guy was gonna keep coming. Mac did what he had to do."
Sawyer respected the ruthless pragmatism Mac had displayed, recognizing a fellow survivor who understood that sometimes violence was the only language dangerous people understood. "Boy's got steel in his spine," Sawyer commented approvingly. "About time someone around here stopped talking and started acting."
But Jack had begun giving speeches about "not becoming savages" while looking pointedly in Mac's direction, his medical oath clashing with the reality of necessary killing. Sayid was torn between understanding the tactical necessity and worrying about slippery slopes that led decent people into becoming the monsters they fought.
And Locke practically glowed with approval, which disturbed Kate more than Jack's moral condemnation. The older man's religious certainty about Mac's "destiny" had found new validation in lethal violence, and Kate feared what directions that approval might push Mac in the future.
She found Mac alone behind the medical area, sitting motionless as sunset painted the sky in shades of blood and gold.
POV: Mac
Kate sat beside him without asking permission, her presence somehow comforting despite the turmoil consuming him.
"Talk to me," Kate said quietly.
Mac's voice cracked like broken glass. "I didn't hesitate. That's what scares me most. When I saw him going after Claire again, I just... acted. Part of me wanted him dead."
Kate took his hand, her grip warm and solid against the chill that had settled into his bones.
"You did what you had to do," Kate said. "That doesn't make you a monster."
"Doesn't it?" Mac's laugh was bitter. "I built a trap specifically designed to kill someone. Used my abilities—my gifts—for murder."
"For protection," Kate corrected. "There's a difference."
"Is there? Because right now it feels like I've become something I never wanted to be."
Kate studied his profile in the dying light, seeing someone she recognized—a person who'd been forced to cross lines they'd never wanted to approach, who carried the weight of necessary choices that civilian morality couldn't accommodate.
"I killed my father," Kate said suddenly.
Mac's head turned toward her, surprise breaking through his self-recrimination.
"He was hurting my mother. Had been for years. And one night I decided I couldn't watch it anymore." Kate's voice was matter-of-fact, but Mac caught the tremor underneath. "I set the house on fire with him inside. Watched it burn. Felt... satisfied."
She paused, gathering thoughts that were clearly difficult to voice.
"Afterward, I felt like you do now. Like I'd become something terrible. But my mother was safe. That had to count for something."
"Did it get easier?" Mac asked.
Kate considered the question seriously. "No. But it became bearable. Because I knew I'd do it again if I had to. That's what protecting people costs sometimes."
Claire appeared from around the medical tent, moving slowly but with purpose. She'd been looking stronger each day since Ethan's death, the constant fear finally lifting from her shoulders.
"Mac," Claire called softly. "Look at me."
He couldn't. The shame was too heavy, the guilt too consuming.
"Please," Claire insisted.
Finally, Mac raised his eyes to meet hers. Claire was crying, tears streaming down her face as she looked at the man who'd saved her life at the cost of his own peace.
"You gave me my life back," Claire said fiercely. "My baby's life. Whatever you had to do to make that happen... I won't let you carry that guilt alone."
She hugged him with desperate strength, and Mac finally broke. The sobs came like a dam bursting, releasing grief and guilt and horror he'd been holding back since driving that stake home. Claire held him while he cried, her presence a anchor in the storm of his self-recrimination.
"I'm sorry," Mac whispered into her shoulder. "I'm so sorry."
"Don't be," Claire said firmly. "You're my family now. Mine and this baby's. You protected us. That's all I'll ever remember."
The absolution didn't erase the guilt—Mac knew it would always be there, a weight he'd carry for whatever remained of his borrowed existence. But it made that weight bearable, gave it meaning beyond simple destruction.
Mac's hands steadied for the first time since the killing. He could feel his Master Builder abilities stirring back to life, ready to create rather than destroy.
When Claire finally released him, Mac returned to his construction work with renewed purpose but fundamentally changed perspective. He built a small memorial stone from beach rocks and placed it at the edge of camp—not forgiveness for Ethan, but acknowledgment of what Mac had become.
Kate watched from a distance, seeing Mac choose to remain human despite everything pushing him toward something darker. The jungle whispers that night sounded almost approving, as if the island itself recognized the necessity of what he'd done.
Mac Kerby was no longer just a healer and builder. He was a protector who understood that sometimes protection required sacrifice—not just of enemies, but of pieces of his own soul that could never be recovered.
The mathematics of survival had claimed another victim, and this time it was Mac's innocence.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
Can't wait for the next chapter of [ Lost: The Ultimate Survivor ]?
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them (20+ chapters ahead!). No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1