"The Elves will not be absent from this quest."
Legolas's voice carried across the terrace with a steadiness that surprised him. His hands wanted to shake—the Ring's pressure hadn't eased since Frodo volunteered—but decades of Elvish discipline kept them still.
Every face turned toward him. Gandalf's expression sharpened with renewed intensity, his suspicion from their earlier conversations visible in the way his eyes narrowed. Elrond's assessment was more subtle but no less penetrating. The other Council members watched with varying degrees of interest or concern.
But Legolas's attention was on the Fellowship. On Frodo, who looked at him with something like hope. On Sam, whose protectiveness extended even to potential allies. On Aragorn, who met his gaze with the recognition of two secret-keepers acknowledging each other.
"I offer my bow and my service to the Ringbearer," Legolas continued. "Until the Ring is destroyed or death takes me."
Elrond studied him for a long moment. Legolas felt the Lord of Rivendell's perception probing at his edges, sensing the wrongness that marked him as different from other Elves. The same wrongness Gandalf had identified. The same wrongness that made the Ring speak to him in ways it shouldn't.
"Nine walkers to oppose Nine Riders," Elrond said finally. "So be it. You shall be the Fellowship of the Ring."
The words fell like a hammer strike, sealing fates that Legolas already knew.
The Council began to disperse, delegates returning to their quarters to discuss implications and prepare reports for distant lords. But the Fellowship remained—nine figures clustered on the terrace, bound together by a commitment none of them fully understood.
Legolas looked at each face and let the weight of knowledge settle over him.
Gandalf, who would fall in Moria. The wizard's apparent death would devastate the company, would leave them leaderless at the worst possible moment. Legolas knew Gandalf would return, transformed and strengthened, but the others wouldn't have that comfort. They would grieve for months before the White Wizard emerged from death.
Could I tell them? The question surfaced with painful familiarity. Could I prepare them for what's coming?
And break the timeline entirely. Gandalf's fall served purposes Legolas couldn't fully predict—his transformation was necessary for what came later. Changing it might mean changing everything.
Boromir, who would yield to the Ring's corruption. The captain of Gondor stood proud and determined now, but Legolas could see the cracks where temptation would find its grip. In months, Boromir would try to take the Ring from Frodo. Would terrify the hobbit into fleeing. Would die defending Merry and Pippin, redeeming himself at the last.
He could be warned. The thought was seductive. A word here, a suggestion there—maybe he could resist.
But Boromir's fall was what drove Frodo to leave the Fellowship. Without that terror, the Ringbearer might have stayed with the group. Might have reached Mordor in company rather than near-solitude. Might have failed entirely.
The hobbits clustered together—Frodo pale but resolute, Sam practical and determined, Merry and Pippin frightened but unwilling to abandon their friends. They would suffer more than anyone in the company. Would be captured, tortured, separated from everything familiar. And they would endure it all, would prove that courage came in unexpected packages.
Gimli's glare had softened slightly—the Dwarf was too honorable to maintain open hostility toward an ally, even an Elvish one. Their friendship would take time and trauma to develop, but it would become something legendary.
And Aragorn. The future king met Legolas's eyes with understanding that went beyond words. Two people carrying secrets they couldn't share, walking toward destinies they couldn't explain.
"We depart in two weeks," Elrond announced. "Use the time to prepare. The road ahead is long and the ending uncertain."
Not entirely uncertain, Legolas thought. I know how it ends. I just don't know if knowing helps.
The Fellowship scattered to their various preparations. Legolas lingered on the terrace, watching the Ring gleam on its pedestal. Frodo would take it soon—would carry it against his heart for months, feeling its weight grow heavier with every step toward Mordor.
"You stepped forward without hesitation."
Gandalf's voice came from behind him—the wizard had waited, observing, analyzing.
"The quest needed nine walkers," Legolas said without turning. "I have abilities that may prove useful."
"Abilities." The word carried skepticism. "Abilities you cannot fully explain. Knowledge you should not possess. A willingness to walk into shadow that suggests you already know what waits there."
Legolas turned to face the wizard. Gandalf's eyes were sharp with suspicion that hadn't diminished since Mirkwood.
"I know what I've told you," Legolas said carefully. "I serve the quest. Whatever else I am, whatever else you suspect—that purpose is genuine."
"And the Ring? It spoke to you last night. I felt its attention shift toward your quarters."
Of course he noticed. Gandalf was an Istar, a Maia in mortal form. Of course he could sense the Ring's movements.
"It speaks to everyone," Legolas said. "It will speak to all of us before this ends."
"Not like it speaks to you." Gandalf's voice dropped. "You understand it, Legolas. You know things about its making that no living Elf should know. That knowledge makes you valuable to the quest—and dangerous to everyone around you."
"I resisted."
"This time." The wizard leaned closer, his presence pressing against Legolas's awareness like the warmth of contained fire. "Can you promise you always will? Can you guarantee that the Ring won't find a way through your defenses?"
The honest answer was no. Legolas knew the timeline—knew that even Frodo would fail at the final moment, claiming the Ring for himself at Mount Doom. If the Ringbearer couldn't resist at the end, what chance did anyone have?
"I can promise to try," Legolas said. "I can promise that my intention is to see it destroyed. Beyond that..."
"Beyond that, none of us can promise anything." Gandalf's expression softened fractionally. "Then we have an understanding. I will watch you, Legolas of Mirkwood. I will intervene if I must. And I will hope that you are what you claim to be—an ally against the darkness rather than another tool of it."
He turned and walked away, leaving Legolas alone on the terrace.
The Ring pulsed gently on its pedestal, patient and eternal.
Fourteen days, Legolas thought. Fourteen days to prepare for a journey I already know.
The knowledge was both comfort and curse. He knew the path. He knew the trials. He knew who would fall and who would rise and how it all ended in fire at the mountain's heart.
And he knew that knowledge alone couldn't protect him. The Ring would try again, and again, and again, until the moment came when his defenses finally failed.
Let it try, Legolas told himself, forcing conviction into the thought. I've spent sixty years preparing for this. I will not fall.
The terrace emptied around him. Somewhere in Rivendell, the other members of the Fellowship were beginning their own preparations. Aragorn would be contemplating the path to his destiny. Boromir would be struggling with pride and duty. The hobbits would be trying to understand what they'd committed to.
And Legolas stood alone, carrying the weight of a future none of them could imagine.
Frodo, thank you, the hobbit had mouthed when Legolas volunteered.
Don't thank me yet, he'd thought in response.
The words felt truer now than ever.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.