The shards of Narsil gleamed with the memory of ancient fire.
Legolas found Aragorn alone in the chamber where the broken sword lay—a memorial to a moment three thousand years past, when Isildur had cut the Ring from Sauron's hand and failed to destroy it. The Ranger stood before the fragments with the posture of someone bearing weight he hadn't asked for.
"It's said the blade will be reforged when the king returns to claim it."
Aragorn didn't turn at Legolas's approach. "Prophecies and legends. Sometimes they're comfort. More often they're chains."
"You carry a heavy burden." Legolas moved to stand beside him, studying the broken blade. His Ring-craft understanding whispered analysis—the sword had touched the Ring once, had been near enough to absorb echoes of power that still lingered in the metal. "The weight of an entire lineage's hope."
"As do you." Now Aragorn turned, his grey eyes meeting Legolas's with perception that cut through surface. "I've watched you since you arrived. You look at the Fellowship like you already know our stories. Like you're waiting for scenes you've memorized to unfold."
The observation was dangerously accurate. Legolas considered denials, deflections, the careful evasions he'd perfected over decades.
"I know things I shouldn't," he admitted instead. The partial truth felt safer than elaborate lies. "I cannot explain them—not fully, not in ways that would make sense. But I can tell you my purpose: to see the Ring destroyed. Whatever else you suspect about me, that intention is genuine."
Aragorn studied him for a long moment. "Gandalf suspects you. Elrond watches you with the wariness he reserves for dangerous unknowns."
"I know."
"And yet you volunteered anyway. Knowing you'd be scrutinized. Knowing the Ring would test you more than others because of whatever knowledge you carry." Aragorn's expression shifted toward something like respect. "That takes either courage or foolishness. Perhaps both."
"Perhaps." Legolas allowed himself a slight smile. "I could say the same about you. The heir of Isildur, walking toward the place where his ancestor's weakness shaped history. That takes something beyond ordinary courage."
Recognition passed between them—two people carrying secrets they couldn't share, walking toward destinies they couldn't fully explain. Not quite trust, but the beginning of understanding.
"We'll need each other before this ends," Aragorn said. "Whatever you're hiding, I hope it serves us all."
"It will. Or I'll die trying."
Aragorn nodded once, accepting the commitment, and turned back to the broken sword. The conversation was over, but something had shifted between them.
Gimli was harder.
The Dwarf sat alone in one of Rivendell's gardens, pointedly ignoring the Elvish beauty around him. His new axe—replacement for the one shattered against the Ring—lay across his knees, and his expression promised hostility to anyone who approached.
Legolas approached anyway.
"I've studied Dwarvish craft," he said without preamble. "Your people's earth-song is remarkable—the way you speak to stone and metal, shaping them through understanding rather than force."
Gimli's eyes narrowed with suspicion. "What would an Elf care for Dwarvish ways?"
"One who wants to see clearly." Legolas sat on a nearby bench, maintaining distance that respected Dwarvish preference for personal space. "The Elves have their own traditions, but they're not the only paths to mastery. Your ancestors understood depths we never explored."
"Pretty words." But something had shifted in Gimli's posture—the hostility remained, but curiosity was beginning to compete with it. "My father told me never to trust an Elf. Said your kind looks down on us, always has."
"Some do." Honesty felt like the right approach with this Dwarf. "Prejudice runs deep on both sides. But we're walking the same road now, toward the same enemy. That has to count for something."
"Does it?" Gimli's challenge was genuine rather than rhetorical. "We reach Mordor, destroy the Ring—then what? Back to old grudges and older wars?"
"Maybe. Or maybe we build something different." Legolas thought of the friendship he knew was coming, the brotherhood that would make Gimli legendary among both their peoples. "Wars end when someone chooses to stop fighting."
Gimli grunted—the Dwarvish equivalent of grudging acknowledgment. "You're strange, Elf. Not like the others."
"So I've been told." Legolas rose, preparing to leave. "I'm not asking for friendship, Gimli son of Glóin. Just willingness to work together until the job is done."
"That, I can offer." Gimli's grip on his axe loosened slightly. "We'll see about the rest."
It was more than Legolas had expected this early. The seed was planted. Time and trial would make it grow.
The hobbits were easiest.
Legolas found them in one of Rivendell's smaller gardens, Merry and Pippin arguing about something trivial while Sam tended to flowers he'd discovered near the path. Frodo sat apart, the distance that would grow over their journey already visible in his posture.
"These are Elvish roses," Legolas said, crouching beside Sam. "They bloom in any season, as long as someone tends them with care."
Sam looked up with the mix of wonder and suspicion that hobbits reserved for all things magical. "They're beautiful, sir. Don't have nothing like this in the Shire."
"Every garden has its treasures." Legolas showed Sam how to touch the petals without damaging them. "Your gardens in the Shire—what do you grow?"
The question opened floodgates. Sam's love for growing things poured out in a torrent of enthusiastic detail—potatoes and tomatoes, flowers and herbs, the simple pleasures of tending soil and watching life emerge. Legolas listened with genuine interest, finding comfort in the gardener's uncomplicated joy.
This is what we're fighting for, he thought. This simplicity. This innocence. The right to care about flowers and potatoes while the world burns around you.
Merry and Pippin drifted over, drawn by Sam's animation. Soon Legolas was fielding questions about Elvish gardens, Mirkwood's forests, the differences between corrupted trees and healthy ones. The conversation was light, easy—a respite from the weight of destiny that pressed on them all.
Frodo watched from his distance, something grateful in his expression.
Gandalf found Legolas as evening fell.
The wizard intercepted him on one of Rivendell's covered walkways, his staff clicking against stone with deliberate weight. His expression held none of the friendliness he showed the hobbits or the respect he offered Aragorn.
"You've been busy," Gandalf observed. "Conversations with Aragorn. Approaches to Gimli. Kindness to the hobbits." He paused, letting the implications settle. "Building alliances before we've even departed."
"Building trust." Legolas met the wizard's gaze without flinching. "We're going to need it."
"Are we?" Gandalf's voice sharpened. "You speak with certainty about a journey that hasn't happened. You prepare as if you know exactly what challenges await. That knowledge—wherever it comes from—makes you valuable to this quest."
"And dangerous." Legolas finished the thought. "You've said as much before."
"And I'll say it again: I am watching you, Legolas Greenleaf—if that is truly who you are. Whatever you hide, it had better serve the quest."
"It does."
"Then we have an understanding." Gandalf's expression didn't soften, but something in his posture relaxed fractionally. "For now."
He walked away, leaving Legolas alone on the walkway as stars emerged above Rivendell's peaks.
Maximum suspicion, the assessment came automatically. He'll be watching every move I make, analyzing every word. One slip, and he'll act.
But Gandalf was also necessary. His guidance, his power, his sacrifice in Moria—all of it served the quest in ways that couldn't be replaced. Legolas would endure the suspicion because the alternative was worse.
The Fellowship ate together that night.
Nine figures gathered around a table in one of Rivendell's dining halls, strangers becoming companions through the simple act of sharing food. Boromir told stories of Gondor's wars. Gimli boasted of Dwarvish achievements. The hobbits contributed Shire tales that made even Aragorn smile.
Legolas watched them all, cataloguing dynamics he would need to manage over the months ahead. Boromir's pride, which would become vulnerability. Gimli's hostility, which would become friendship. The hobbits' fear, which would become courage.
And Gandalf's suspicion, which would never fully fade.
Strangers becoming companions, Legolas thought. Not yet friends. But we will be.
The meal ended and the Fellowship scattered to their quarters. Legolas lingered in the hallway, reluctant to face another night of the Ring's whispers.
A servant approached with a folded message. "From Lord Elrond, Prince Legolas. Just arrived."
Legolas unfolded the paper and read the single line inscribed there:
The Lady of Lórien sends word: she knows you are coming, and she is waiting.
Galadriel.
The name carried weight that the other Fellowship members couldn't understand. The Lady of Light, bearer of Nenya, one of the Three Rings that had been created without Sauron's direct touch. Her perception exceeded even Gandalf's—and she would see things in Legolas that the wizard could only suspect.
She's waiting. The implications unfolded with uncomfortable clarity. She already knows something is wrong with me. And she wants to see for herself.
Legolas folded the message and tucked it away. Another challenge. Another test. Another opportunity for his secrets to unravel.
Fourteen days until departure, he reminded himself. Then the road to Mordor. Then Lothlórien.
Then Galadriel.
He walked toward his quarters, feeling the Ring's distant attention following him through Rivendell's halls.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.