Chapter 5: THE STORAGE UNIT
[Queens, New York — Two Days Later, 3:47 AM]
The Caffrey Storage Facility sat between a tire shop and a laundromat on a commercial strip in Astoria that time had forgotten. Chain-link perimeter, mercury vapor lights casting everything in yellow-green, a single booth at the entrance with a sliding window.
I'd spent the previous day running reconnaissance. Drive-bys at different hours, cataloguing shift changes, camera positions, foot traffic patterns. Two guards: day shift, a retired cop with a bad hip who walked the rows once an hour, and overnight, a kid in his twenties who watched movies on a tablet propped against the window and left his booth exactly twice per shift — once at midnight for the vending machine, once at three AM for a cigarette behind the dumpster.
It was 3:47. The kid was behind the dumpster. His cigarette glow pulsed in the gap between the metal containers.
The facility's office entrance was a glass door with a deadbolt that looked newer than the building. I didn't go through it. The loading dock on the north side had a rolling gate secured by a padlock that was older than I was. The shackle was corroded. A decent torsion wrench and a rake would have opened it in thirty seconds.
I didn't have lock picks. What I had was a clipboard, a laminated ID badge from a print shop in Midtown, and the most powerful social engineering tool in existence: a man with a clipboard at four AM looks like he's supposed to be there.
The kid came back from his cigarette break. I was standing at the office door with my clipboard, frowning at the lock as if my key wasn't working.
"Hey." I knocked on the glass. Held up the badge — CITY OF NEW YORK DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND MENTAL HYGIENE, printed that afternoon in a twenty-minute rush job. The photo was Keller's face. The name was invented. "Environmental Services. I've got a ventilation compliance check scheduled for this facility. The notification should have gone out two weeks ago."
The kid looked at the badge. Looked at the clipboard. Looked at my face. His expression was the universal mask of a twenty-two-year-old confronted by bureaucratic authority at four in the morning: confused, slightly annoyed, and entirely willing to cooperate if it meant going back to his tablet faster.
"Nobody told me about any inspection."
"Nobody ever does." I held up the clipboard, which contained printed pages of genuine NYC ventilation compliance codes I'd downloaded from the city's website. Dense, incomprehensible, official-looking. "I need access to the records room and the interior units to check ductwork. Should take about thirty minutes."
"It's almost four AM."
"Environmental spot-checks are conducted outside business hours to assess conditions without occupant interference. Section 47, paragraph 3." There was no such section. The kid didn't check.
He buzzed me in.
---
[Records Room — Caffrey Storage Facility]
The records room was a closet with a filing cabinet and a desk that had seen decades of coffee rings. Rental agreements were filed alphabetically by last name, which was useless. I needed unit numbers.
A cross-reference binder sat on a shelf behind the desk — unit numbers mapped to account names. I flipped to 714.
Account holder: Equinox Consulting LLC. Monthly auto-payment from a Chase account. The LLC had been registered eight months ago, which put its creation roughly at the same time Kate had started working for Adler. My criminal memory flagged the name instantly — Equinox Consulting appeared in Season 2, buried in the financial records that Mozzie had traced back to Adler's web of shell companies.
I photographed the rental agreement, the payment records, and the LLC documentation with the burner phone. Six photos, taken in clean light, stored in a folder I'd review later.
The kid was back at his booth. I could hear a muffled action movie through the wall. I had maybe twenty minutes before he started wondering why a ventilation inspection required this much time in the records room.
---
[Unit 714 — Interior Storage Corridor]
The corridor smelled of dust and cardboard and the faint mineral tang of concrete. Fluorescent tubes buzzed overhead, one of them flickering at a frequency that made my teeth itch. Unit 714 was halfway down the third row — standard size, roll-up door, secured by a padlock that was better than the loading dock's but still a commercial-grade pin tumbler.
Keller's hands knew locks. The muscle memory was buried deep, not in the conscious layer I operated from but in the tendons and joints themselves. I pulled two bobby pins from my pocket — primitive, embarrassing, the kind of thing that would make a real locksmith wince — and bent them into a tension wrench and a rake.
The first pin slipped. My fingers were clumsy — Keller's dexterity filtered through my inexperience, like trying to play a piano I'd never practiced on but somehow understood. The second attempt caught the first pin stack. The third popped the second. The tension wrench turned and the shackle released with a click that echoed down the empty corridor.
Ninety seconds. Keller would have done it in fifteen. But Keller had been picking locks since he was a teenager, and I'd been in this body for two weeks.
The door rolled up. I pulled a penlight from my pocket and swept the beam across the interior.
File boxes. Stacked three high, maybe twenty of them, labeled with dates and alphanumeric codes. A laptop — silver, closed, power cord wrapped around it — sat on a folding table in the back. Beside it, a small fireproof safe with a digital keypad.
I went for the file boxes first.
The first three contained financial records — bank statements, wire transfer confirmations, corporate registration documents. All connected to shell companies. All routed through accounts that my criminal memory was cross-referencing against Adler's known financial architecture from Seasons 2 and 3. The match rate was above ninety percent.
The fourth box stopped me.
Manila folders. Internal FBI letterhead. Documents stamped CONFIDENTIAL in red ink that had faded to pink. The header on the first page read: OPERATION MENTOR — OPR REVIEW, AGENT G. FOWLER PRESIDING.
Garrett Fowler's investigation of Peter Burke. The one Adler had commissioned through back channels — use OPR, the FBI's internal affairs division, to put pressure on Peter while Adler hunted the music box. Kate's job was to photograph these documents and deliver them to Adler's intermediaries. She'd been doing it for months.
I flipped through the pages. Fowler's name appeared in operational directives, surveillance authorizations, internal memos. Peter Burke's file was thick — years of case reports being scrutinized for procedural errors that could be weaponized. The scope was larger than I'd expected this early in the timeline. Adler had started pressuring Peter before Neal had even escaped prison.
The laptop might contain more. The safe definitely did. But the laptop needed a password and the safe needed a code, and I had neither. What I could take were the files — selectively, three folders that wouldn't leave an obvious gap in the stacks. Enough to prove the conspiracy existed. Enough to give me leverage on Fowler, evidence of Adler's operation, and confirmation that Kate was compromised.
I slid the laptop into my jacket. The folders went inside the clipboard binder. The safe I left untouched — too heavy to carry, too obvious if missing, and I couldn't crack digital keypads with bobby pins and optimism.
I relocked the unit, returned down the corridor, and dropped the bobby pins into a trash can. At the office door, I waved to the kid through the glass.
"All clear. Ductwork's within code. You'll get the report in six to eight weeks."
He didn't look up from his tablet. "Cool."
I walked to the rental car three blocks away. The engine caught on the second try, and I pulled onto the expressway heading toward Manhattan with a stolen laptop, three classified FBI files, and the architectural blueprint of a conspiracy I'd watched unfold on television.
The clock on the dashboard read 4:22 AM. Dawn was an hour away. The hotel bed was calling.
But first — one thing.
In the fourth file box, before I'd found Fowler's operation, there had been a photograph tucked between accounting ledgers. Kate Moreau at a gallery opening, wine glass in hand, a genuine smile on a face that usually performed its expressions with careful precision. Neal stood beside her, one arm around her waist, his own smile broad and careless and completely unaware that the woman leaning against him was photographing FBI documents for the man who would eventually kill her.
She looked happy. They both did. The kind of happiness that lives in a moment because neither person knows what's coming after.
In eight months, Kate would be dead.
I merged onto the BQE and drove.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.