Chapter 38: THE TROLLEY PROBLEM GAUNTLET — Part 1
The neighborhood square had been transformed.
Where yesterday there had been a fountain and benches and the carefully calibrated architecture of paradise, now there were tracks. Real metal rails stretching across the transformed space, converging at switch points, splitting into branches. A trolley sat at the starting position—gleaming, massive, impossibly heavy.
And tied to the tracks at various points, figures.
Dean's passive VR confirmed what his eyes were seeing: simulated humans, but with enough reality to scream. Enough weight to be crushed. Enough presence to make the moral mathematics terrifyingly concrete.
"Welcome," Shawn announced from a raised platform at the edge of the arena, "to what I'm calling the Ethical Gauntlet. A series of scenarios designed to test the methodology of this neighborhood against traditional Bad Place techniques."
The coalition stood in a group near the center of the square—Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani, Jason, with Dean slightly behind them. Michael flanked Shawn on the platform. The enforcement demons had arranged themselves as an audience, Bad Janet slouching against a pillar with an expression of profound boredom.
"The rules are simple," Shawn continued. "Each of you will face a trolley problem. Not theoretical—physical. You'll have a lever. You'll have a choice. And you'll live with the consequences." He smiled. "Michael claims his approach produces deeper, more sustained suffering than traditional methods. Let's see if he's right."
Dean's hands were clenched at his sides. Every instinct screamed at him to use his abilities—to scan Shawn for weaknesses, to construct arguments, to find some angle that would make this stop. But Val's demons were still searching for the energy signature, and any use of his powers would paint a target on his chest.
Pure human, he reminded himself. You're just a resident. You're just a scared man watching his friends get tested.
It wasn't entirely acting.
"First up," Shawn announced. "Eleanor Shellstrop."
Eleanor stepped forward. Her shoulders were set, her expression carefully neutral, but Dean could see the tension in her jaw.
"Your scenario is personal," Shawn said. "On track A, we have five individuals you wronged during your life. Five people whose suffering you directly caused through your actions."
The simulations materialized—faces Dean didn't recognize, but Eleanor clearly did. Her breath caught. Her hands started to tremble.
"On track B," Shawn continued, "we have you. Or rather, a perfect simulation of you, with all your memories, all your experiences, all your fears."
A second Eleanor appeared on the alternate track, bound and terrified, her eyes wide with the specific panic of someone who knew exactly what was coming.
"The trolley will kill whoever is on the track you don't protect." Shawn's smile widened. "Save the five you wronged, or save yourself. Standard utilitarian calculus with a twist of guilt. You have thirty seconds."
The trolley started moving.
Dean watched Eleanor's face cycle through emotions he couldn't track without active VR—fear, shame, anger, something that might have been resignation. She looked at the five people she'd hurt. She looked at herself. She looked at the lever.
Fifteen seconds.
Ten seconds.
Five.
Eleanor pulled the lever.
The trolley switched tracks. The simulation of Eleanor screamed, tried to struggle free, failed. The impact was brutal—metal against flesh, the sound of something being destroyed.
Eleanor dropped to her knees and vomited.
The real Eleanor. The one who'd just watched herself die.
"Excellent," Shawn said, his voice carrying no emotion whatsoever. "Self-sacrifice under utilitarian pressure, with the added complexity of guilt-driven motivation. Michael, I have to admit—this is producing interesting data."
Dean wanted to go to Eleanor. Wanted to help her up, comfort her, acknowledge what she'd just done. But Shawn was watching, and any display of genuine care would undermine the torture narrative they were selling.
Instead, he stayed frozen, fists clenched, feeling the helplessness burn through him like acid.
This is what it costs, he thought. This is what surviving Shawn requires.
Eleanor stood slowly, wiping her mouth. Her eyes found Dean's across the square. Something passed between them—understanding, maybe. Or just shared horror at what the next hour would bring.
"Next," Shawn announced. "Chidi Anagonye."
Chidi stepped forward. His signature was already churning with anxiety, the paralysis-patterns Dean had learned to recognize during their earliest conversations.
"Your scenario is different," Shawn said. "No complex emotional variables. Just speed."
Five trolley tracks appeared, arranged in sequence like stations on a train line. At the end of each track, simulated people waited to die.
"Five problems. Five decisions. Ten seconds each." Shawn's smile had teeth in it. "Make a choice or watch them die. Ready?"
Chidi opened his mouth to respond.
The first trolley started moving.
"Track A has two people. Track B has one. The lever diverts A to B. Ten seconds." Shawn counted down. "Nine. Eight. Seven."
Chidi's hands were shaking. His face had gone gray.
"Six. Five. Four."
"I—I need to consider—"
"Three. Two. One."
The trolley hit. Three simulated people died while Chidi stood frozen, unable to choose.
"Track two," Shawn announced immediately. "Four people versus two. Ten seconds starting now."
Dean watched Chidi's identity fragment under the pressure. This was the man who had spent his entire life agonizing over decisions, developing frameworks to avoid the terror of wrong choices. And Shawn had designed a scenario that made frameworks impossible—no time to think, no space to analyze, just choose or watch people die.
By the third scenario, Chidi was pulling levers blindly, unable to engage with the moral content at all. By the fourth, he was sobbing. By the fifth, he collapsed after making his choice, unable to stand.
"Fascinating," Shawn murmured to Val. "The suffering metrics here exceed traditional torture by nearly thirty percent. There's something about attacking identity itself that produces remarkable results."
Dean's hands were shaking now. Not with fear—with rage. The kind of rage that wanted to tear this entire arena apart, consequences be damned, just to stop what was happening to his friends.
But he couldn't move. Couldn't act. Couldn't do anything except stand in the crowd like a helpless bystander while Shawn took apart everyone he'd come to care about.
Two more, he told himself. Tahani and Jason. Then I get to talk.
It felt like an eternity away.
Want more? The story continues on Patreon!
If you can't wait for the weekly release, you can grab +10, +15, or +20 chapters ahead of time on my Patreon page. Your support helps me keep this System running!
Read ahead here: [ patreon.com/system_enjoyer ]
we just added free chapters on unwrittenrealm.com — plus the whole novel is translated into 14 languages. read it in your language for free.