Chapter 13: Playing Normal
POV: Sam Barton
The Mystic Grill on Saturday afternoon buzzes with the kind of comfortable chaos that makes small towns feel alive. Caroline drags Sam through the entrance, her blonde hair catching afternoon sunlight streaming through windows, her energy infectious despite the supernatural paranoia gnawing at his consciousness.
"Mandatory fun date," she'd announced this morning with the kind of determined cheerfulness that brooks no argument. "We're celebrating our two-month anniversary."
"We've been official for three weeks," Sam had pointed out.
"But we had that maybe-date at the comet festival, so it counts. I've planned everything. Milkshakes, terrible jokes, photo session for Instagram. You're going to relax if it kills you."
Now they settle into their usual booth while Sam's clones send constant mental updates that make relaxation impossible: "Stefan and Elena three booths over, looking intense. Damon's at the bar, scanning everyone like he's shopping for dinner. Bonnie just walked in—she looks distressed."
"Stay alert but don't interfere unless there's immediate danger," Sam commands mentally.
Caroline spreads her meticulously planned anniversary agenda across the table—a color-coded itinerary that includes optimal milkshake consumption timing and designated selfie opportunities.
"Okay," she says with the intensity of a general planning military strategy, "we start with chocolate milkshakes, move to the jukebox dance sequence, then photobooth documentation of our adorable relationship."
"She's trying so hard to make this perfect," Sam realizes, watching the slight tension in Caroline's shoulders despite her bright smile. "She needs this. Normal. Human. Safe."
Sam forces himself to set aside supernatural concerns and focus completely on the girl across from him.
"You know what I love about your planning?" he says, genuinely meaning it.
"That it's obsessive and slightly insane?"
"That it shows how much you care about the people in your life. You want things to be perfect because you want people to be happy."
Caroline's expression shifts from manic energy to something softer, more vulnerable.
"Most people think I'm neurotic."
"Most people are idiots who don't recognize dedication when they see it."
She reaches across the table, squeezing his hand with fingers that tremble slightly.
"You make me feel like I'm enough, exactly as I am."
Sam lifts her hand to his lips, kissing her knuckles softly.
"You're more than enough. You're everything."
For the next hour, Sam commits completely to being Caroline's boyfriend instead of a supernatural guardian. They dance to the jukebox—badly, laughing at their own lack of rhythm. They pose for ridiculous photos in the booth, Caroline making faces that would scandalize her mother. She feeds him fries while talking about college plans and dreams of traveling to Europe after graduation.
"This is what normal feels like," Sam thinks as Caroline steals a sip of his milkshake. "This is what I'm fighting to preserve."
The spell breaks when Bonnie Bennett rushes to their table, pale and shaking like she's seen a ghost. Her dark skin has an unhealthy pallor, and her hands won't stop trembling as she grips the back of Sam's chair.
"It happened again," she whispers urgently, glancing around to make sure no one's listening. "All the candles in my room—they lit themselves when I got angry at my mom."
Caroline immediately shifts into protective mode.
"Bonnie, are you okay? You look like you're about to pass out."
Elena and Stefan appear at their table as if summoned, concern written across both their faces. Stefan's vampire hearing has probably caught fragments of the conversation.
Sam sees his opportunity and takes it.
"Bonnie, remember what we talked about? About your gift?"
She nods desperately, brown eyes wide with fear and confusion.
"I think I'm losing my mind."
"You're not losing anything. You're finding something that's always been part of you."
Sam stands and gently guides her toward the exit, Caroline following protectively while Stefan and Elena trail behind. Outside in the parking lot, away from curious ears, Sam turns to face Bonnie with complete seriousness.
"Your family's power isn't a curse, Bonnie. It's who you are. Your ancestors, your grandmother—they all had this gift. You're not broken or crazy. You're awakening."
"Awakening to what?" Bonnie's voice cracks with desperate need for answers.
"To magic. To abilities that most people can't understand. And that's terrifying, but it's also incredible."
Sam coaching her through breathing exercises, channeling his memories of Bennett witch techniques from the show.
"Feel the energy inside you. Don't fight it or fear it. Accept it. Guide it instead of letting it control you."
Bonnie closes her eyes, focusing on his voice and the strange warmth that's been building in her chest for weeks. When she opens them again, there's a new resolve that wasn't there before.
"I can feel it," she whispers. "Like electricity under my skin."
"That's your power. Your birthright. And with practice, you'll learn to control it completely."
Stefan watches from the doorway, and Sam can see the vampire's realization crystallizing: Sam knows about the supernatural world. Has known all along.
[QUEST COMPLETE: BONNIE'S AWAKENING - STAGE 2]
[REWARD: +300 EXP]
[BONNIE BENNETT: CONFIDENCE BOOST - MAGICAL DEVELOPMENT ACCELERATED]
After Bonnie leaves with Elena, visibly calmer but still processing, Stefan approaches Sam with the careful neutrality of someone reassessing a potential threat.
"Walk with me," Stefan says quietly.
They stroll toward the town square while Caroline chats with friends, giving them privacy for a conversation that could reshape everything.
"You know," Stefan says without preamble. "About me, about the supernatural world, about Bonnie's magic. How?"
Sam makes a calculated decision. Partial truth wrapped in believable lies.
"My parents researched the occult extensively. I inherited their... sensitivity. I see patterns, sense danger, feel supernatural presences. That's how I knew about Bonnie's magic and why I drink vervain."
Stefan studies his face with vampire intensity, looking for deception.
"You're trying to protect people."
"Yes."
"That makes you an ally. But Damon doesn't trust you, and neither does Elena fully. You need to be careful."
Sam extends his hand, meeting Stefan's green eyes with steady determination.
"I'm not your enemy, Stefan. I want the same thing you do—to keep this town and the people I care about safe."
Stefan considers for a long moment, then shakes his hand firmly.
"Cautious allies, then. I'll share information when I can, and I'll try to keep Damon from killing you. But that's getting harder every day."
"I know. He's running out of patience with my interference."
"Then stop interfering."
Sam shakes his head.
"I can't do that. Not when people's lives are at stake."
Stefan's expression shifts to something like respect.
"Then get stronger. Fast. Because when Damon decides you're a threat instead of an annoyance, you'll need more than vervain and luck to survive."
[QUEST COMPLETE: STEFAN'S TRUST]
[REWARD: +400 EXP]
[CURRENT EXP: 750/4,000 TO LEVEL 7]
[RELATIONSHIP UPGRADE: STEFAN SALVATORE - CAUTIOUS ALLY]
[BONUS: WILL SHARE LIMITED INFORMATION]
[BONUS: WILL DEFEND AGAINST DAMON'S AGGRESSION]
[RELATIONSHIP DEEPENED: CAROLINE FORBES - SOULMATE TRAJECTORY DETECTED]
[BONUS: +20% ALL STATS WHEN NEAR CAROLINE]
That evening, Sam walks Caroline home through tree-lined streets that look deceptively peaceful in the golden hour light. She chatters about their perfect date, hand warm in his, completely unaware that her boyfriend just formed an alliance with a vampire.
"Today was exactly what I needed," Caroline says, swinging their joined hands between them. "Just normal teenage stuff. No drama, no stress, just us."
"If only she knew how much drama I'm juggling to give her these moments of normal."
"I had fun too," Sam replies honestly. "We should do this more often."
"Really? You're not just saying that because I'm incredibly persuasive?"
"You are incredibly persuasive. But I mean it. These moments with you—they're the best part of my day."
Caroline stops walking and turns to face him, blue eyes serious in the fading light.
"Sam, can I ask you something?"
"Here it comes. She's too perceptive to ignore the inconsistencies forever."
"Of course."
"Are you in some kind of trouble? I don't mean school trouble or family stuff. I mean real trouble. Because lately it feels like you're carrying weight that's too heavy for one person."
The question hits Sam like a physical blow. Caroline sees through his carefully maintained facades with terrifying accuracy, recognizes the stress he thought he was hiding.
"She knows something's wrong. She just doesn't know what."
Sam cups her face in his hands, thumbs tracing her cheekbones.
"I'm trying to help people, Caroline. Sometimes that puts me in complicated situations. But I promise you—I'm not in danger I can't handle."
It's not technically a lie, though it's not exactly the truth either.
Caroline searches his eyes for several heartbeats, then nods slowly.
"Okay. But if that changes—if you ever are in over your head—you'll tell me, right? I know I'm just a high school student, but I'm stronger than I look."
"I know you are. And yes, if I ever need help, you'll be the first person I call."
She stretches up to kiss him, soft and sweet and real, and for a moment Sam forgets about vampires and systems and all the supernatural chaos swirling around them.
"This is what I'm fighting for. Her smile, her laugh, her terrible organizational habits, her fierce loyalty. Everything that makes Caroline Forbes who she is."
As he watches her disappear into her house, waving from the front door, Sam calculates the day's gains: Stefan as an ally, Bonnie's confidence growing, Caroline's trust deepening despite growing awareness that something's different about him.
But through his mental link, Clone One's voice carries worrying news: "Damon left the boarding house an hour ago. Haven't seen him since. Could be hunting."
"Keep tracking. If he approaches any of our friends, intervene immediately."
"Copy that. But Sam? This can't last much longer. He's going to figure out we're not human."
"I know. That's why we need to get stronger faster."
Sam looks up at the stars beginning to appear in the darkening sky, same celestial patterns he memorized during his past life but now viewed through the lens of supernatural knowledge and responsibility.
Stefan's right—he needs more power. Damon's patience is a finite resource, and when it runs out, vervain and clever tactics won't be enough to survive the vampire's wrath.
But tonight, Caroline is safe in her house, Bonnie is learning to embrace her heritage instead of fearing it, and Stefan stands between Sam and immediate death.
Small victories. But in Mystic Falls, sometimes small victories are all that stand between hope and horror.
+1 CHAPTER AFTER EVERY 3 REVIEWS
MORE POWER STONES == MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
Love [ The Vampire Diaries: The Clone Sovereign ]? Unlock More Chapters and Support the Story!
with exclusive access to 27+ chapters on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!